
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.4Mixed reviews with some stating rooms were comfortable, but others mentioned issues like size and maintenance.
Cleanliness
8.3Many reviews commented positively about the cleanliness of the rooms.
Service
8.9Staff were generally described as helpful and friendly.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Zürich, CH
1.5 km (0.95 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.5 km.
Motel One Zürich: 0.03 km (0.02 mi)
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In: 1.5 km (0.95 mi)
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
7.5/10Motel One Zürich
8.4/10Hotel Montana Zürich
7.4/10Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
6.3/10VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
5.5Mixed/poor for comfort in heat: several reports of no usable AC during heat wave, uncomfortable mattress for some, broken bathroom sliding door and noise issues on ground-floor rooms.
Motel One Zürich
8.4Mixed reviews with some stating rooms were comfortable, but others mentioned issues like size and maintenance.
Hotel Montana Zürich
6.9Rooms were small but generally comfortable.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
4.5Rooms suffered from poor maintenance: thin/ill-fitting bedding, shower/head problems, sheer curtains letting in light, and significant overheating with no AC or fan options.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
6.0Mixed to below-average: multiple reviews mention ants, insufficient cleaning (broken glass left in room), and worn corridor carpets, though some rooms were reported as generally clean.
Motel One Zürich
8.3Many reviews commented positively about the cleanliness of the rooms.
Hotel Montana Zürich
6.0Some areas described as smelly and issues noted with hygiene.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
4.0Multiple guests reported the room was only 'semi clean' or outright unclean (stains on bedhead and floor); general maintenance and cleaning problems noted.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
10.0Consistently praised: very close to the centre, public transport and train station; repeatedly cited as a primary pro.
Motel One Zürich
9.1Several reviews noted the excellent location of the hotel.
Hotel Montana Zürich
9.0Location is praised for being close to Zurich station.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
8.5Location praised by multiple reviewers as convenient, though some noted street noise and nearby restaurant smells — overall a strong location but noisy at night.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
9.0Generally friendly and helpful staff (helped with extra fan, positive interactions), but there are notable service lapses (rude handling of laundry access) — overall leans positive.
Motel One Zürich
8.9Staff were generally described as helpful and friendly.
Hotel Montana Zürich
8.0Staff were generally polite and helpful, although some instances of rudeness were reported.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
8.5Mixed but with some clear positives: several guests found check-in easy and got automated codes; however there were complaints about lack of on-site staff, slow/unhelpful customer service in certain calls. Scored higher to reflect smooth self-service check-in mentioned while acknowledging hit-or-miss human support.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
—Motel One Zürich
—Hotel Montana Zürich
—Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
—VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
7.5Not specifically reviewed; assigned target overall rating.
Motel One Zürich
7.8Breakfast options received multiple complaints regarding variety and quality.
Hotel Montana Zürich
7.5Breakfast varied by review; some positive notes on selection, but chaos was reported.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
6.3Not directly reviewed as a hotel service (no on-site F&B feedback); assigned the target overall rating.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
5.0Below average: missing/limited amenities reported (AC not available/used, no hand soap provided, small elevator, restricted laundry access); some basic items supplied on request (fan).
Motel One Zürich
8.1Several comments indicated lack of amenities such as tea and coffee or mini bars.
Hotel Montana Zürich
7.5Amenities mostly met expectations, though issues with facilities were mentioned.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
4.5Key amenities lacking or in poor condition: no air-conditioning or fans, elevator often broken, very limited kitchenware and supplies, and missing basics like dish soap or sufficient utensils.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
8.0Perceived as a bit expensive (typical for Switzerland), but many guests find the location and short-stay convenience justify the price.
Motel One Zürich
7.9Critiques on high price relative to provided amenities affected the rating.
Hotel Montana Zürich
6.9Value seems fair given the location, but some noted pricing concerns.
Swiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
8.6Several guests noted the property could be acceptable for a short stay ('one or two nights') if expectations are low; rated higher to reflect perceived value for short/ budget stays despite shortcomings.
VISIONAPARTMENTS Brandschenkestrasse - self check-in
Heinrich-Zollinger-DenkmalMotel One Zürich
Heinrich-Zollinger-DenkmalHotel Montana Zürich
Hände über der StadtSwiss Star Longstreet - Self Check-In
Kugellager oder runde Steine (I)