The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection vs Similar Hotels

Positive comments about spaciousness and comfort of rooms.

Reviews noted comfortable beds and stylish bathrooms contributing to a pleasant stay.

Rooms were generally comfortable and adequate, but issues with TV reported.

Many reviews praised the cleanliness, but some mentioned issues like noise and functionality affecting comfort.

Numerous reviews mention the rooms being clean and well-maintained.

Some concerns about bathroom drainage smell and noise from other rooms.

Reviewed as convenient for Edinburgh but with noted distance concerns.

A recurring positive highlight with excellent access to Edinburgh and beautiful surroundings.

Good location but some mentioned noise from the main road.

Consistently positive remarks about the friendly and helpful staff throughout various reviews.

Guests praised the friendly and helpful staff in multiple reviews.

Excellent staff and service, particularly noted for helpfulness.

Many reviews appreciated the restaurant offerings and quality of food.

No specific mentions of food and drink, so considered standard quality for this hotel tier.

Food was generally excellent, although breakfast availability was inconsistent.

Amenities mentioned positively, though some minor issues with air conditioning and views.

While most amenities were satisfactory, a few reviews suggested additional kitchen items could be improved.

Limited amenities on specific dates, with restaurant and bar hours causing inconvenience.

General sentiment suggests good value for price, despite some complaints about breakfast costs.

Guests expressed that the overall experience provided good value for the price.

Overall value felt acceptable given the stay experience.