
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.4General feedback noted comfort but some rooms described as dated.
Location
9.9The location was highlighted as excellent, with many positive mentions.
Service
9.9Staff were frequently described as friendly and attentive.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
8.5/10The Dolphin
9.1/10Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
9/10The Resolution Hotel
8.9/10Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
7.7Some comments on room comfort and furniture provided.
The Dolphin
8.4General feedback noted comfort but some rooms described as dated.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
8.8Rooms are lovely, warm, and comfortable, but some had issues with noise.
The Resolution Hotel
8.7Rooms described as comfortable but with some concerns regarding temperature and pillow softness.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
8.2Rooms are clean, some issues with room smell and corridors mentioned.
The Dolphin
7.9Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly with the shower and bed linen.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
8.3Generally clean and tidy, but some reports of noise and thin walls affecting comfort.
The Resolution Hotel
9.0General sentiment and repeated mentions indicate that the hotel maintains high cleanliness standards.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
9.2Great location, convenient for parking with access to local attractions.
The Dolphin
9.9The location was highlighted as excellent, with many positive mentions.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
9.3Beautiful building in a lovely area close to amenities and scenic walks.
The Resolution Hotel
9.3The location is frequently praised as ideal for exploring the area.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
9.2Staff are friendly and accommodating, fostering a welcoming atmosphere.
The Dolphin
9.9Staff were frequently described as friendly and attentive.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
9.3Friendly and welcoming staff throughout the hotel.
The Resolution Hotel
9.2Staff are consistently described as friendly and helpful.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
—The Dolphin
—Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
—The Resolution Hotel
—Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
8.7Generally good food quality but some dishes received mixed reviews.
The Dolphin
9.4Breakfast received consistent praise, indicating high quality.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
8.8Breakfast was plentiful with a good variety, but some might prefer full-service options.
The Resolution Hotel
8.5Breakfast receives mixed reviews with some disappointments noted but overall is seen positively.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
8.7Amenities available include restaurant and bar on-site.
The Dolphin
8.9Amenities were mostly seen positively; notable mentions for breakfast and fridge service.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
9.3Great amenities including a continental breakfast and comfortable communal areas.
The Resolution Hotel
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier; while there are mentions of a lack of parking and noise issues, overall amenities are adequate.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
7.7Food pricing noted as high compared to portion size.
The Dolphin
8.9Several reviews suggested the hotel is good value for the location and service provided.
Ruswarp Hall - Whitby
8.8Paid extra for breakfast, which was worth it; mostly good value overall.
The Resolution Hotel
8.7While considered a bit expensive, it is considered worth the price for the quality received.
Penny Hedge, Whitby by Marston's Inns
Penny HedgeThe Dolphin
Polar BearRuswarp Hall - Whitby
Brother WilliamThe Resolution Hotel
Gansey Knitter