
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Cleanliness
8.3Mentioned concerns about missing basic items like shampoo and hairdryer.
Location
9.3Stunning views and a private dock enhance the location experience.
Service
9.8Horacio is repeatedly praised as an excellent host with great service.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.8/10Hotel Carolina Bacalar
9/10Amigos Hotelito
9.2/10Cedro Rojo
7.8/10Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.7Rooms are described as comfortable, but one review expressed dissatisfaction about a lack of amenities.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
9.3Rooms were generally praised for their quality and comfort.
Amigos Hotelito
8.3Rooms scored lower due to needing redesign and some bedding issues.
Cedro Rojo
8.5Rooms well maintained with air conditioning and hot water.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.8Guests mentioned cleanliness as a positive aspect.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
8.3Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, including a dirty pool.
Amigos Hotelito
8.3Mentioned concerns about missing basic items like shampoo and hairdryer.
Cedro Rojo
6.5Issues with room cleanliness noted, particularly in the bathroom.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
9.3The hotel is well-located by the lagoon, though some would prefer closer access to the center.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
9.3Several reviews noted the beautiful lakeside location.
Amigos Hotelito
9.3Stunning views and a private dock enhance the location experience.
Cedro Rojo
7.5Location mentioned as somewhat distant from the central park.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
9.2Staff was noted as friendly, but some found the service lacking at times.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
9.8Multiple reviews highlighted the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff.
Amigos Hotelito
9.8Horacio is repeatedly praised as an excellent host with great service.
Cedro Rojo
8.5Staff were attentive and responsive during the stay.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
—Hotel Carolina Bacalar
—Amigos Hotelito
—Cedro Rojo
—Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.8Breakfast received positive remarks, though additional meal options were mentioned as needed.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
8.8Food was generally well-received, though breakfast options were considered limited.
Amigos Hotelito
9.3Breakfasts are highlighted as delicious and a positive aspect.
Cedro Rojo
7.5No breakfast included but options nearby.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.3Limited amenities mentioned; guests expressed a desire for more activities on-site.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
8.8Good access to kayaks and canoes, although limited loungers were noted.
Amigos Hotelito
9.3Great amenities like kayaks and a private dock are frequently mentioned positively.
Cedro Rojo
8.0Basic amenities available, with positives noted about room features.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
8.2Some guests felt prices were too high for the offerings.
Hotel Carolina Bacalar
8.8Some guests felt the price was too high for the offered value.
Amigos Hotelito
9.3Overall experience and amenities justify a great value perception.
Cedro Rojo
8.0Good pricing mentioned relative to service and location.
Hotel Aldea 19 Bacalar
What SUPHotel Carolina Bacalar
Cenote NegroAmigos Hotelito
Cenote NegroCedro Rojo
Cenote Negro