Our pick
English
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.2Rooms can be small, but some offer amazing views and are well-decorated.
Cleanliness
8.3Overall clean but some mentions of odors and small room size.
Location
9.3Great location near the airport and within walking distance to restaurants and attractions.
Close alternatives
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Forth Reflections Self Catering
Queensferry, GB
★ 4-star9/100 reviews
0.49 km (0.31 mi) from original
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Orocco Pier8.2
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection7.0
Cleanliness
Dakota Edinburgh8.7
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection7.6
Location
Orocco Pier9.3
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection8.4
Amenities & Facilities
Orocco Pier8.8
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection8.1
Value
Orocco Pier8.7
Dakota Edinburgh8.1
Forth Reflections Self Catering amenity advantages
Pets allowed
Dakota Edinburgh amenity advantages
Air conditioningFitness center24-hour front deskConcierge serviceLift / Elevator
Orocco Pier amenity advantages
Beachfront
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.85 km.
Forth Reflections Self Catering: 0.49 km (0.31 mi)
Dakota Edinburgh: 1.3 km (0.83 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
8.2/10Forth Reflections Self Catering
9/10Dakota Edinburgh
8.8/10Orocco Pier
8.8/10Rooms
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
7.0Mixed room reports: some large, comfortable rooms with great views; others were in a basement with small windows, unfurnished or very dark, plus issues like a flickering main light and very firm mattress—room quality is notably inconsistent and below average.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
8.2Rooms are clean but some minor issues with lighting and noise from the bed.
Orocco Pier
8.2Rooms can be small, but some offer amazing views and are well-decorated.
Cleanliness
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
7.6Mixed notes: several reviewers praised cleanliness and a very clean room, but there are isolated negatives (hair found in sink/shower and one unfurnished/basement room described as poor), so cleanliness is slightly below the hotel average.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
8.7Rooms were reported as very clean and comfortable.
Orocco Pier
8.3Overall clean but some mentions of odors and small room size.
Location
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
8.4Location praised (close to airport, train station, good parking, great views and historic setting) but several guests reported noise from trains/bridge and occasional disruption, so location scores well but not perfect.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
9.2Perfect location mentioned, convenient for the airport.
Orocco Pier
9.3Great location near the airport and within walking distance to restaurants and attractions.
Service
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
9.2Staff frequently described as friendly, helpful and attentive in multiple reviews (warm welcome, good care), though a few reports mention busy or unhelpful moments (slow check-in, locked hotel, poor responsiveness). Overall service sentiment leans positive.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
9.2Staff were consistently described as friendly, helpful, and attentive.
Orocco Pier
9.2Staff were very attentive, friendly, and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
—Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
—Orocco Pier
—Food & Breakfast
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
9.1Food and beverage received strong praise (beautiful food, great service, good breakfast noted), though there was at least one operational issue with breakfast timing/availability; overall sentiment is very positive.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
9.2Breakfast and evening meals consistently praised as excellent.
Orocco Pier
8.8Food quality was praised, especially in the restaurant.
Amenities & Facilities
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
8.1Amenities include free coffee, free car park, pub on-site and decent food/service; however wifi issues (slow or non-working) and understaffing at times were noted, giving amenities a generally positive but slightly imperfect rating.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
8.7Amenities mentioned include a cozy atmosphere and good service.
Orocco Pier
8.8Good amenities, although specific mentions were limited.
Value
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
8.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Forth Reflections Self Catering
—Dakota Edinburgh
8.1The £50 check-in charge raised some confusion but was manageable.
Orocco Pier
8.7Generally good value, though some felt it was pricey during peak times.
Landmarks
The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection
Landmark data unavailableForth Reflections Self Catering
Landmark data unavailableDakota Edinburgh
Battle of Jutland MemorialOrocco Pier
Provost john Reid Memorial Fountain