Our pick
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
Porirua, NZ
★ 4-star9.8/1026 reviews
0.25 km (0.15 mi) from original
English
Whitby sea view vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Very roomy and comfortable house with everything needed.
Cleanliness
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
10.0Great location mentioned in reviews.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
Porirua, NZ
★ 4-star9.8/1026 reviews
0.25 km (0.15 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location10.0
The Post Hotel6.7
Cleanliness
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location9.5
Whitby sea view7.0
Location
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location10.0
The Post Hotel8.8
Service
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location10.0
The Post Hotel8.3
Food & Breakfast
Hilltop Blue Sky House9.5
The Post Hotel7.8
Amenities & Facilities
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location10.0
The Post Hotel7.3
Value
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location9.5
The Post Hotel7.7
Whitby sea view amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Hilltop Blue Sky House amenity advantages
Pets allowedPhysical distancing in dining areas
The Post Hotel amenity advantages
Concierge serviceLift / ElevatorLaundryLuggage storageWheelchair accessible
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 4.9 km.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location: 0.25 km (0.15 mi)
The Post Hotel: 5.2 km (3.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Whitby sea view
8.7/10Hilltop Blue Sky House
9.1/10Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
9.8/10The Post Hotel
7.7/10Rooms
Whitby sea view
8.4Rooms were clean and modern but some guests found the beds uncomfortable.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
8.4Rooms were generally comfortable but some guests noted issues with uncomfortable beds and furniture.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
10.0Very roomy and comfortable house with everything needed.
The Post Hotel
6.7Rooms were reported as smaller than expected and some maintenance issues.
Cleanliness
Whitby sea view
7.0Several mentions of dirtiness and rude behavior, particularly regarding dirty dishes.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
7.5Several reviews reported issues like dirty curtains, yellow-stained bed sheets, and mold on the front door.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Post Hotel
7.3Generally clean but issues with noise and maintenance reported.
Location
Whitby sea view
8.9Convenient for a stopover, although a bit remote without a car.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
9.5The location was frequently praised for its perfect setting and great views, although the steep drive was a concern.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
10.0Great location mentioned in reviews.
The Post Hotel
8.8Excellent location, central to shops and amenities.
Service
Whitby sea view
9.4Hosts were described as friendly and hospitable; good communication prior to stay.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
10.0The host was described as incredibly responsive, polite, and friendly, contributing positively to the stay.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
10.0Specific sentiment from text reflects welcoming and homey service.
The Post Hotel
8.3Staff were described as friendly and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
Whitby sea view
—Hilltop Blue Sky House
—Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
—The Post Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
Whitby sea view
8.4Guests mentioned bringing their own breakfast and using kitchen facilities.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
9.5Food and beverage specifics were not covered, but the overall satisfaction indicates good quality.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Post Hotel
7.8Restaurant and bar received positive comments.
Amenities & Facilities
Whitby sea view
9.4Access to family kitchen and lounge, and lovely dog mentioned positively.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
8.5Guests appreciated the kitchen space and appliances, although there were mentions of insufficient supplies.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
10.0Well appointed property had everything we needed.
The Post Hotel
7.3Amenities mentioned as satisfactory, but lack of air conditioning noted.
Value
Whitby sea view
8.9Overall a good stay, but aspects of cleanliness affected perceived value.
Hilltop Blue Sky House
9.4Most guests felt the pricing was reasonable for the amenities and overall stay experience.
Retro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Post Hotel
7.7Fair for the price considering location and comfort.
Landmarks
Whitby sea view
Bradey's Bay ParkHilltop Blue Sky House
Ascot ParkRetro 4 bedroom home, warm and welcoming, quiet location
The Quarterdeck LookoutThe Post Hotel
Porirua Peace Memorial