Our pick
English
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.8Most rooms are described as comfortable, though some comments about small bathrooms exist.
Cleanliness
9.4Reviews consistently describe the accommodation as pristine and spotlessly clean.
Location
9.4The location is mentioned positively, being within walking distance to amenities.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
Penzance, GB
★ 4-star9/101,576 reviews
2.5 km (1.5 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Bay Lodge8.8
The Longboat Inn7.0
Cleanliness
Bay Lodge9.4
The Longboat Inn7.5
Location
Hotel Penzance Harbour View9.8
The Longboat Inn8.9
Service
Bay Lodge9.9
The Longboat Inn8.9
Food & Breakfast
Bay Lodge9.9
The Longboat Inn8.9
Amenities & Facilities
Bay Lodge9.4
The Longboat Inn8.0
Value
Bay Lodge9.3
The Longboat Inn8.0
Bay Lodge amenity advantages
Beach
The Longboat Inn amenity advantages
Family rooms
Hotel Penzance Harbour View amenity advantages
Swimming poolRoom serviceConcierge serviceLaundryWheelchair accessible
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
9.7/10Bay Lodge
9.5/10The Longboat Inn
8.2/10Hotel Penzance Harbour View
9/10Rooms
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
8.8Most rooms are described as comfortable, though some comments about small bathrooms exist.
The Longboat Inn
7.0Thin walls, dated rooms, and several issues reported.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
8.8Comfortable rooms with some issues like damp stains and broken sink plug.
Cleanliness
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.4Reviews consistently describe the accommodation as pristine and spotlessly clean.
The Longboat Inn
7.5Rooms very dated and not very clean.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
8.3Issues with cleanliness in the first room and comments about a tired bathroom.
Location
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.4The location is mentioned positively, being within walking distance to amenities.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Location is perfect, right across from railway station.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
9.8Convenient location with stunning views.
Service
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.9Clare and the staff are repeatedly praised for their hospitality and helpfulness.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Staff excellent and helpful, very pleasant and accommodating.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
9.3Staff were welcoming, but there were serious concerns about availability during check-in.
Sleep & Noise
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
—The Longboat Inn
—Hotel Penzance Harbour View
—Food & Breakfast
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.9Guests rave about the quality and variety of breakfasts served.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Food is absolutely amazing for breakfast and dinner.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
9.3Generally good, with particular praise for the Cornish breakfast.
Amenities & Facilities
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.4Free parking and convenient access to the surrounding area are noted.
The Longboat Inn
8.0Good food option downstairs and friendly staff.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
9.3Decent amenities but limited parking.
Value
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
—Bay Lodge
9.3Guests feel they received excellent value, especially considering the complimentary breakfast.
The Longboat Inn
8.0Generally good value, but some felt not reflecting the room rate.
Hotel Penzance Harbour View
8.3Expensive breakfast and charged parking were seen as drawbacks.
Landmarks
The Annex, Tregoddick Barn
Landmark data unavailableBay Lodge
Princess May recreation groundThe Longboat Inn
Humphry DavyHotel Penzance Harbour View
Princess May recreation ground