Our pick
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/10218 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
English
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.8The room quality was often described as clean, spacious, and well-maintained, aligning with guest expectations.
Cleanliness
9.3The apartment was extremely clean as mentioned in multiple reviews, but there were concerns about the need for more regular cleaning.
Location
10.0Multiple reviews praised the property's great location, being in the middle of everything and within walking distance to restaurants.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.4/10189 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star8.6/10314 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
Our pick
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/10218 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed10.0
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy8.5
Cleanliness
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment9.4
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy7.1
Service
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment10.0
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed9.5
Food & Breakfast
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino9.3
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed8.5
Amenities & Facilities
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed9.5
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy7.5
Value
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed10.0
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy8.5
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
9.5/10Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4/10703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
8.6/10Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.5/10Rooms
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
10.0Spacious, comfortable, and beautiful room.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4Rooms are described as comfortable, elegant, and spacious.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
8.5Overall stay nice, but minor complaints about bedding.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.8The room quality was often described as clean, spacious, and well-maintained, aligning with guest expectations.
Cleanliness
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
8.5Mixed feedback; clean but mentioned cockroaches.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4Reviews frequently mention cleanliness and how the place was very clean.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
7.1The bed linen was dirty and had not been changed from previous guests.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3The apartment was extremely clean as mentioned in multiple reviews, but there were concerns about the need for more regular cleaning.
Location
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
10.0Perfect location; close to everything.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.6The location is often highlighted as excellent and convenient to shopping.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
9.6Property was neat and perfectly located.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
10.0Multiple reviews praised the property's great location, being in the middle of everything and within walking distance to restaurants.
Service
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
9.5Mostly positive with minor issues at check-in.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
10.0Guests appreciated the personal touch and good communication from the host.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
9.5Staff are very friendly and helpful.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.8Dina was highlighted as an amazing host who was very responsive and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Sleep & Noise
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
—Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
—703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
—Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
—Food & Breakfast
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
8.5Restaurant under renovation; alternatives were provided.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
8.8Limited feedback, but overall satisfaction with snacks provided.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3Complimentary drinks were mentioned as a nice touch, enhancing the positive experience.
Amenities & Facilities
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
9.5Good amenities, but minor improvements needed.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.3Amenities such as comfortable beds and cleanliness are praised.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
7.5Requires just a little more attention to amenities for better comfort.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3Amenities included a big TV with DSTV and Netflix, though some drawbacks included extra cleaning fees.
Value
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
10.0Great value considering location and comfort.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
8.9Good value mentioned, though one review noted a 'weird' smell.
703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
8.5Paid a premium for cleanliness, but service was good.
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
8.8Some guests felt the price was high for self-catering, impacting perceived value for money.
Landmarks
Menlyn Maine Residences - Napoli with king sized bed
Jimmy AvesMenlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
Jimmy Aves703 Menlyn Maine Residences, The Trilogy
Jimmy AvesTop Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
Jimmy Aves