Our pick
Harbour Hotel Padstow
Padstow, GB
★ 4-star8.7/102,771 reviews
3.1 km (1.9 mi) from original
English
The Old Mill House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.6Rooms were generally clean and well-presented, though some had issues with noise and views.
Cleanliness
8.5General positivity about cleanliness from reviews, but some inconsistencies noted.
Location
9.1Multiple mentions of excellent location, particularly for town access and views.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Harbour Hotel Padstow8.6
The Old Custom House7.3
Cleanliness
Harbour Hotel Padstow8.5
Bay Retreat Villas7.6
Location
The Old Custom House9.4
Bay Retreat Villas8.7
Amenities & Facilities
The Old Custom House8.8
Bay Retreat Villas8.1
Value
Bay Retreat Villas9.1
The Old Custom House8.3
Harbour Hotel Padstow amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceLift / ElevatorMeeting/banquet facilitiesBreakfast in the room
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Old Mill House
9.5/10The Old Custom House
8.6/10Bay Retreat Villas
8.5/10Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.7/10Rooms
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
7.3Mixed feedback, with some rooms needing maintenance and being described as tired.
Bay Retreat Villas
8.1Spacious and comfortable but some items were described as tired.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.6Rooms were generally clean and well-presented, though some had issues with noise and views.
Cleanliness
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
7.9Multiple mentions of cleanliness issues, including stains and tired room conditions.
Bay Retreat Villas
7.6Issues with cleaning mentioned. Dining table was sticky, thick dust present.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.5General positivity about cleanliness from reviews, but some inconsistencies noted.
Location
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
9.4Excellent location noted in several reviews, with a fantastic view.
Bay Retreat Villas
8.7Great location for visiting the area, easy parking.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
9.1Multiple mentions of excellent location, particularly for town access and views.
Service
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
9.3Staff were consistently described as friendly, attentive, and helpful.
Bay Retreat Villas
9.1General satisfaction with service, no specific complaints noted.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
9.1Staff were often described as friendly and accommodating, contributing positively to the experience.
Sleep & Noise
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
—Bay Retreat Villas
—Harbour Hotel Padstow
—Food & Breakfast
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
8.9Food quality was well received, but the continental breakfast options were lacking.
Bay Retreat Villas
8.6No specific issues or comments regarding food and beverage.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.5Mixed reviews on food, with some good experiences but instances of disappointment with options.
Amenities & Facilities
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
8.8Good amenities mentioned, though some areas could benefit from upgrades.
Bay Retreat Villas
8.1Well-equipped kitchen and overall good amenities, some requests for improvements.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.4Positive mentions of amenities, though some improvements highlighted.
Value
The Old Mill House
—The Old Custom House
8.3General sentiment suggests good value for the location and service, but issues impact it.
Bay Retreat Villas
9.1Great value for money, especially for the standard of the villas.
Harbour Hotel Padstow
8.6Value perceived as good, but some guests felt charges for breakfast were excessive.
Landmarks
The Old Mill House
Landmark data unavailableThe Old Custom House
The Capitol CinemaBay Retreat Villas
Old MacDonalds FarmHarbour Hotel Padstow
The Capitol Cinema