
City Garden Hotel Makati
Manila, PH
0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Manila, PH
0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original
Rooms
8.5Rooms were generally described as comfortable and clean, but with some minor issues noted.
Location
9.1Location was frequently praised as very central and convenient, close to restaurants and attractions.
Service
9.0Overall, guests appreciated the helpful and friendly staff, indicating strong service quality.




Manila, PH
0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
8.9/10Berjaya Makati Hotel
7.4/10Herald Suites Polaris
8.5/10City Garden Hotel Makati
8.6/10The Belamy House Managed by HII
8.4Generally clean and comfortable rooms with many mentioning comfortable beds, but mixed reports include an uncomfortable bed for one guest, smaller room sizes for others and noise issues in some rooms.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
6.4Rooms reported as old and some issues with maintenance; however, spaciousness and comfort mentioned.
Herald Suites Polaris
8.0Positive mentions of room decor, but noise from air conditioning and issues like shared keys noted.
City Garden Hotel Makati
8.5Rooms were generally described as comfortable and clean, but with some minor issues noted.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
9.0Rooms and public areas repeatedly described as clean with a pleasant scent throughout the building; one review noted a pool odor on the 5th floor affecting nearby rooms.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
5.4Many reviews mention that the hotel is old and not clean, indicating a deteriorating standard.
Herald Suites Polaris
8.1Various reviews indicate a general sense of cleanliness, but specific complaints about issues like stains suggest room for improvement.
City Garden Hotel Makati
8.3Some guests mentioned cleanliness issues with the bathroom and waiting times for elevator, indicating moderate concerns.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
9.2Central Makati location lauded for proximity to nightlife, restaurants and sights; several reviewers noted it is very convenient though some rooms hear street/traffic noise.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
8.9Strong appreciation of the hotel's central location near shopping and other attractions.
Herald Suites Polaris
9.1The hotel is well-located near amenities and attractions, with many positive mentions.
City Garden Hotel Makati
9.1Location was frequently praised as very central and convenient, close to restaurants and attractions.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
9.5Staff consistently praised as extremely friendly, helpful and attentive (assisting with luggage, great reception and service across multiple reviews).
Berjaya Makati Hotel
8.9Positive comments about friendly and helpful staff, with notable mentions of excellent service.
Herald Suites Polaris
9.1Multiple reviews highlight the exceptional staff and prompt service.
City Garden Hotel Makati
9.0Overall, guests appreciated the helpful and friendly staff, indicating strong service quality.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
—Berjaya Makati Hotel
—Herald Suites Polaris
—City Garden Hotel Makati
—The Belamy House Managed by HII
7.8Breakfast was frequently criticised (not memorable; lack of halal options for some guests); however there are many nearby dining options that compensate for in-house F&B limitations.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
7.4Breakfast quality perceived as lacking with old options; some positive mentions.
Herald Suites Polaris
8.1Breakfast is à la carte and reasonable but could have more options.
City Garden Hotel Makati
8.6Breakfast was specifically mentioned as very good by several guests.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
8.8Rooftop bar and pool highlighted as a key asset; in-room features like a bidet mentioned and basic on-site amenities present, though some services (breakfast options) are limited.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
6.9Amenities are outdated and in need of renovation, particularly the indoor pool.
Herald Suites Polaris
8.6The hotel offers good amenities like a restaurant and scenic installations, but some areas could enhance user experience.
City Garden Hotel Makati
8.3Amenities like breakfast and pool facilities received mixed feedback due to operational issues.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
9.3Multiple reviewers emphasize good/fair price for the location and quality, with at least one noting direct bookings were cheaper than third-party sites.
Berjaya Makati Hotel
7.4Perceived as reasonable but some budget options provide better experiences.
Herald Suites Polaris
8.5Good value for the quality of services and location provided.
City Garden Hotel Makati
8.4Mixed value perception based on amenities versus price; some guests expected more.
The Belamy House Managed by HII
Bel-Air 2 ParkBerjaya Makati Hotel
Trump buildingHerald Suites Polaris
Bel-Air 2 ParkCity Garden Hotel Makati
Trump building