By the Lake 29 - Menaggio by LoveComo vs Similar Hotels

Several reviews mentioned dated decor and uncomfortable beds, impacting the overall room quality.

Rooms with street views were small; views from the lake side are spectacular.

Rooms are comfortable with great views, balconies and good air conditioning, but several guests note small size and dated/antique decor that could benefit from updating.

Most reviews noted the hotel was clean, but some indicated issues with specific items needing replacement.

Some guests noted issues with sound insulation and street view rooms.

Mixed cleanliness: several guests praised general upkeep, but there was a notable report of a dry urine smell in a bathroom and at least one guest cleaned it themselves — suggests inconsistent housekeeping that needs attention.

The hotel has a perfect location by the lake and close to the ferry, appreciated by many guests.

The hotel is ideally located by the lake and close to ferry docks.

Outstanding location: repeatedly described as 'perfect' or 'hard to beat' — right in the heart of Menaggio, steps from restaurants, cafés, ferry and with strong lake views.

Exceptional service was frequently noted, especially by the housekeeping staff and dining personnel.

Guests praised the staff for friendliness and attentiveness.

Mixed to below-par service: a few staff (e.g., a kind gentleman at reception) were praised, but multiple reviews mention inattentive or uninterested staff, forgotten breakfast orders and lack of smiles, indicating inconsistent training/morale.

Breakfast received high praise, with guests enjoying the variety and quality offered.

Restaurant praised for quality, despite some concerns about cost.

Mixed F&B: a few guests enjoyed the café, but several complaints about café/terrace food quality and breakfast service (orders forgotten) indicate inconsistent food & beverage standards.

Good amenities were noted, but some areas, like the pool, could be improved in temperature.

Good amenities available including pool and lake access.

Excellent amenities: consistently praised rooftop pool (panoramic views), sauna, private parking/garage, elevator and reliable air conditioning — these are highlight features for guests.

Some guests felt the price was too high for the standard of the room quality.

Pricing was competitive for the region, although some felt the restaurant was pricey.

Some guests feel the hotel is pricey for a three-star property and mention peak-season pricing; overall value is acceptable given location and amenities but perceived as slightly high by several reviewers.