Our pick
English
The One 'Private Island' Escape vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.6Rooms were described as comfortable and spacious, with good amenities.
Cleanliness
9.1Guests noted that rooms were clean but there was a broken table lamp in one room.
Location
9.6Perfect location in the main town, with easy access to the beach and local amenities.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
Cat Ba, VN
★ 0-star8.9/10114 reviews
1.4 km (0.84 mi) from original
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
THe IRELAND9.6
The One 'Private Island' Escape8.2
Cleanliness
THe IRELAND9.1
The One 'Private Island' Escape7.7
Location
The One 'Private Island' Escape10.0
Thuỷ Anh Hotel8.6
Service
THe IRELAND10.0
Thuỷ Anh Hotel9.1
Food & Breakfast
THe IRELAND8.6
Thuỷ Anh Hotel7.1
Amenities & Facilities
The One 'Private Island' Escape9.7
Thuỷ Anh Hotel7.6
Value
The One 'Private Island' Escape10.0
Thuỷ Anh Hotel8.6
The One 'Private Island' Escape amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessibleBilliards or pool tableBeach umbrellas
Thuỷ Anh Hotel amenity advantages
WiFi availableFree WiFi24-hour front deskLaundryMeeting/banquet facilities
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The One 'Private Island' Escape
9.1/10Thuỷ Anh Hotel
8.3/10Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
8.9/10THe IRELAND
9.5/10Rooms
The One 'Private Island' Escape
8.2Complaints about hard beds and unpleasant bathroom smells.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
8.6Rooms were described as clean and spacious, though sea views are obstructed.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
8.6Rooms were noted as spacious but with some issues mentioned in cleanliness and maintenance.
THe IRELAND
9.6Rooms were described as comfortable and spacious, with good amenities.
Cleanliness
The One 'Private Island' Escape
7.7Multiple mentions of unclean conditions, dirty bathrooms, and bugs.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
8.1There were complaints about the cleanliness of the bathroom and linens.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
8.1Multiple reviews mention poor cleanliness, particularly in regards to dirty bathrooms and sticky utensils.
THe IRELAND
9.1Guests noted that rooms were clean but there was a broken table lamp in one room.
Location
The One 'Private Island' Escape
10.0Private island location is beautiful and tranquil, enhancing the overall experience.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
8.6Location is central but affected by construction noise.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
9.6Frequent mentions of the ideal location for walking and nearby attractions.
THe IRELAND
9.6Perfect location in the main town, with easy access to the beach and local amenities.
Service
The One 'Private Island' Escape
9.2Service was inconsistent; some staff were friendly, but many were unmotivated.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
9.1Staff were friendly and helpful in arranging tours and services.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
9.6Positive experiences with staff were noted, especially with Mr. Huyen's exceptional service.
THe IRELAND
10.0The host was friendly and accommodating, resolving issues immediately.
Sleep & Noise
The One 'Private Island' Escape
—Thuỷ Anh Hotel
—Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
—THe IRELAND
—Food & Breakfast
The One 'Private Island' Escape
8.2Limited food options and quality issues noted, specifically with unclean conditions.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
7.1Breakfast was seen as uninspired and not recommended.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
7.6Limited food options reported and subpar breakfast experience.
THe IRELAND
8.6Breakfast was decent but limited choices; pancakes were noted as undercooked.
Amenities & Facilities
The One 'Private Island' Escape
9.7Good range of activities and amenities available for guests.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
7.6Limited breakfast options and some mentioned inadequate facilities.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
9.1Amenities include excursions and services, but some expectations were not met.
THe IRELAND
9.1Air conditioning and hot showers worked well, but some room amenities needed maintenance.
Value
The One 'Private Island' Escape
10.0Affordability and beautiful scenery justify the costs.
Thuỷ Anh Hotel
8.6Cheap accommodation but misrepresented regarding views.
Aroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
9.1Good value reflected by offered services at lower prices than online bookings.
THe IRELAND
10.0Guests felt they received excellent value for the price paid.
Landmarks
The One 'Private Island' Escape
ShipThuỷ Anh Hotel
StairsAroma Cat Ba Sea View Hotel
StairsTHe IRELAND
Điểm Biểu tượng ngắm Vịnh Cát Bà