
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.4The room was beautifully decorated and warm and cosy.
Cleanliness
9.4The rooms and public spaces are tastefully decorated and comfortable.
Location
9.9Location was perfect and with parking.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.2 km.
The Countryman: 5.6 km (3.5 mi)
Pedn-Olva: 6.8 km (4.2 mi)
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.2/10Pedn-Olva
9/10Harbour View House
9.6/10The Countryman
9.2/10The White House at The Tinners Arms
8.7Rooms considered comfortable, though some needed revamping.
Pedn-Olva
8.3Generally lovely rooms, but many complaints about room size.
Harbour View House
9.4The room was beautifully decorated and warm and cosy.
The Countryman
8.6While rooms were generally clean, some reviews indicated that furnishings are outdated.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.2Many reviews praised the cleanliness of the rooms and facilities.
Pedn-Olva
8.3Standard quality for this hotel tier, some concerns about room size affecting perceived cleanliness.
Harbour View House
9.4The rooms and public spaces are tastefully decorated and comfortable.
The Countryman
8.6Some reviews mention that the hotel didn't leave a very neat and tidy impression and noted dust in the room.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.2Multiple mentions of an ideal location for walking and scenic settings.
Pedn-Olva
9.8Exceptional views and a great location highlighted by many guests.
Harbour View House
9.9Location was perfect and with parking.
The Countryman
9.6The hotel is well-located for exploring St Ives and offers good parking.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.7Staff were consistently described as friendly and accommodating.
Pedn-Olva
9.8Fantastic staff and friendly service noted in multiple reviews.
Harbour View House
9.9The team are attentive and helpful.
The Countryman
9.6Many reviews highlight the hosts as friendly, accommodating, and attentive.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
—Pedn-Olva
—Harbour View House
—The Countryman
—The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.2Delicious food and great breakfast options were highlighted.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Breakfast was nice, but evening meals were noted as poor by one guest.
Harbour View House
9.9The food quality is top drawer and delicious.
The Countryman
9.6Breakfast received high praise as being very good with a variety of choices.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.2The pub atmosphere and shared kitchen were positively noted.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Good facilities overall, though some amenities like coffee availability at breakfast were lacking.
Harbour View House
8.9Nice room, comfortable. Good breakfast.
The Countryman
9.6Guests enjoyed the garden, lounge, and facilities offered.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
9.1Guests felt they received good value for their stay, especially for the food.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier, considering the location and views.
Harbour View House
9.4The rates are reasonable.
The Countryman
8.5Some reviews suggest that value for money was not ideal due to cleanliness and outdated furnishings.
The White House at The Tinners Arms
Zennor QuoitPedn-Olva
Epidauros IIHarbour View House
Shanty Baba's Lantern Ghost StorywalkThe Countryman
Knill's Monument