Our pick
English
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4 vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
7.5Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness that warranted a lower score.
Service
8.9Staff were noted as excellent and helpful, especially in the face of challenges.
Food & Breakfast
8.5Food quality received positive mentions with good breakfast options.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
Newbury, GB
★ 3-star7.8/1089 reviews
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M47.8
Bacon Arms, Newbury6.4
Cleanliness
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M47.8
Bacon Arms, Newbury5.5
Location
The Chequers Hotel9.0
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M47.8
Service
The Chequers Hotel9.0
Bacon Arms, Newbury6.9
Food & Breakfast
The Lodge Hotel8.5
The Chequers Hotel6.5
Amenities & Facilities
The Lodge Hotel8.0
Bacon Arms, Newbury7.5
Value
The Chequers Hotel8.5
Bacon Arms, Newbury6.4
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4 amenity advantages
Fitness facilities
The Lodge Hotel amenity advantages
Lift / ElevatorPets allowed
The Chequers Hotel amenity advantages
Room serviceConcierge serviceLaundryBreakfast in the roomElectric vehicle charging station
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8/10Bacon Arms, Newbury
7/10The Lodge Hotel
8/10The Chequers Hotel
7.8/10Rooms
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Property described as lovely; room/property quality praised
Bacon Arms, Newbury
6.4Reviews noted outdated and poorly maintained rooms.
The Lodge Hotel
6.9Mixed sentiments regarding room size and comfort, with some rooms being cramped and noisy.
The Chequers Hotel
6.5Critiques on room comfort, old decor, and issues with heating were noted.
Cleanliness
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
Bacon Arms, Newbury
5.5Multiple reviews indicated poor cleanliness, including dirty coffee cups and smell of smoke.
The Lodge Hotel
7.5Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness that warranted a lower score.
The Chequers Hotel
7.0Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness and smell in the rooms.
Location
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Multiple mentions of a great, central location
Bacon Arms, Newbury
9.0Multiple reviews praised the location as a major positive.
The Lodge Hotel
8.5Location is consistently praised as convenient for various needs.
The Chequers Hotel
9.0The location received consistent praise, being central and convenient.
Service
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Host repeatedly described as friendly/fabulous in reviews
Bacon Arms, Newbury
6.9Mixed comments on service with some staff being unhelpful.
The Lodge Hotel
8.9Staff were noted as excellent and helpful, especially in the face of challenges.
The Chequers Hotel
9.0Staff are friendly and received positive sentiments across multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
—Bacon Arms, Newbury
—The Lodge Hotel
—The Chequers Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
Bacon Arms, Newbury
7.0Food described as typical pub food, lacking variety.
The Lodge Hotel
8.5Food quality received positive mentions with good breakfast options.
The Chequers Hotel
6.5Breakfast service was poorly managed, impacting the overall sentiment.
Amenities & Facilities
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
Bacon Arms, Newbury
7.5Limited mentions; standard amenities present but need improvement.
The Lodge Hotel
8.0Amenities received mixed feedback, with some noting basic facilities but also mentioning pleasant dining.
The Chequers Hotel
7.5Mixed reviews on amenities and availability such as breakfast and facilities.
Value
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
7.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
Bacon Arms, Newbury
6.4Some reviews felt the price was high for the quality received.
The Lodge Hotel
7.9Value perception varied based on experience with services and issues faced.
The Chequers Hotel
8.5Generally reasonable value, though some guests felt it did not meet the 4-star standard.
Landmarks
The Old Library - Within easy reach of Train Station and Racecourse - Excellent road links via the A34 and M4
Landmark data unavailableBacon Arms, Newbury
Goldwell ParkThe Lodge Hotel
Stroud GreenThe Chequers Hotel
The Symphony Of The Trees