
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Consistently described as clean, comfortable, and beautifully furnished.
Cleanliness
9.3Reviews mention 'very clean' indicating high cleanliness standards.
Location
9.8Repeated mentions of excellent location close to Matakana Village, highly praised by reviewers.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.3/10Matakana Motel
9.1/10White Cottage
9.2/10Garden Apartment
9.4/10Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Rooms were modern, comfortable, and well-furnished.
Matakana Motel
8.7Spacious and comfortable rooms. Some issues with the shower door mentioned.
White Cottage
9.3Stylishly furnished with plenty of space and comfy beds.
Garden Apartment
9.3Consistently described as clean, comfortable, and beautifully furnished.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Reviews highlight the villa and units as beautiful, clean, and tidy.
Matakana Motel
9.2Clean, organised and quiet. Room was spotless, comfortable and roomy.
White Cottage
9.4The cottage was clean and nicely furnished, contributing positively to the experience.
Garden Apartment
9.3Reviews mention 'very clean' indicating high cleanliness standards.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Great location close to Matakana village and other attractions.
Matakana Motel
9.7Fantastic location, central but quiet, and right near the Saturday market.
White Cottage
9.4Great location, handy for market and shops.
Garden Apartment
9.8Repeated mentions of excellent location close to Matakana Village, highly praised by reviewers.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.7No specific service issues mentioned; positive experiences indicated.
Matakana Motel
9.7Staff were friendly and couldn’t do enough for us. Wonderful service when we requested a sofabed.
White Cottage
9.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Garden Apartment
9.8Positive comments about the owner being helpful and providing excellent communication.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
—Matakana Motel
—White Cottage
—Garden Apartment
—Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Local coffee provided appreciated; overall good experience.
Matakana Motel
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
White Cottage
9.4Good supermarket nearby with fresh food options.
Garden Apartment
8.8Not explicitly mentioned, assigned 'Standard quality for this hotel tier'.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Amenities mentioned such as quality linen and nearby facilities.
Matakana Motel
8.7Nice facilities, including the pool, although some updates are needed, like the tramp.
White Cottage
8.4Some amenities were lacking, such as additional tissue supplies.
Garden Apartment
9.3Guests appreciated the thoughtful extras like coffee pods and chocolates.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
9.2Overall positive experiences justify the value perception.
Matakana Motel
8.2Expectations not met due to crowding and the price might not match the experience.
White Cottage
8.3A bit pricey given the position on a main road.
Garden Apartment
9.2Overall feedback suggests a strong value relative to the quality of stay.
Island ambience in the heart of Matakana
Matakana War MemorialMatakana Motel
Matakana War MemorialWhite Cottage
Matakana War MemorialGarden Apartment
Matakana War Memorial