Our pick
English
Open Hotel Makka vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
8.0Some guests reported issues with AC cleanliness impacting their stay.
Location
10.0Multiple reviews praise the hotel's convenient location near the Haram.
Service
9.5Guests indicated excellent service upon arrival and throughout their stay.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
Makkah, SA
★ 4-star8.9/10289 reviews
0.83 km (0.52 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments9.4
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل6.8
Cleanliness
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments8.4
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل6.3
Location
Selat Al Bait Hotel10.0
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل8.3
Service
Selat Al Bait Hotel9.5
Open Hotel Makka8.4
Food & Breakfast
Selat Al Bait Hotel9.5
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل7.3
Amenities & Facilities
Selat Al Bait Hotel9.5
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل7.8
Value
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments8.9
Open Hotel Makka8.1
Open Hotel Makka amenity advantages
Spa/wellness center
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل amenity advantages
Concierge serviceLift / ElevatorLaundryLuggage storage
Selat Al Bait Hotel amenity advantages
Fitness centerRestaurantMeeting/banquet facilitiesShuttle service (free)
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments: 0.83 km (0.52 mi)
Selat Al Bait Hotel: 1.9 km (1.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Open Hotel Makka
8.1/10Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
7.8/10Selat Al Bait Hotel
9.1/10Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.9/10Rooms
Open Hotel Makka
8.2Rooms are mentioned as good and well-maintained with no complaints noted.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
6.8Comments about small rooms and some discomfort for families led to a moderate score.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
8.4Some guests noted rooms were small for larger groups.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
9.4Rooms are spacious and modern, with good amenities.
Cleanliness
Open Hotel Makka
7.9The hotel is described as clean, but there were concerns about a specific food experience.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
6.3Numerous mentions of cleanliness being an issue, resulting in a lower score.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
8.0Some guests reported issues with AC cleanliness impacting their stay.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.4Several reviews mentioned cleanliness concerns, especially regarding the shower area.
Location
Open Hotel Makka
8.4The hotel is conveniently located near the main road and close to significant transportation options.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
8.3Comments show favorable views on the location's proximity to key attractions.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
10.0Multiple reviews praise the hotel's convenient location near the Haram.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.9Good location close to the Haram but some difficulty finding it.
Service
Open Hotel Makka
8.4Many reviews praised the staff's professionalism and willingness to help guests.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
9.3Multiple reviews highlight the nice and helpful staff, justifying a higher rating.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
9.5Guests indicated excellent service upon arrival and throughout their stay.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
9.4Service was often praised, but there were complaints about slow responses.
Sleep & Noise
Open Hotel Makka
—Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
—Selat Al Bait Hotel
—Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
—Food & Breakfast
Open Hotel Makka
7.7Some issues with food taste were mentioned; however, overall quality was noted as satisfactory.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
7.3No direct comments on food, assigning a standard score for this category.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
9.5Reviews highlight the quality and variety of food offered at the hotel.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.4No specific mentions, but room service could have small improvements.
Amenities & Facilities
Open Hotel Makka
7.9Basic amenities are provided, but specific recommendations highlight some food concerns.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
7.8Standard amenities mentioned but some reviews indicated lack of sufficient parking.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
9.5The hotel provides good amenities including shuttle services to the Haram.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.9Amenities were generally good but some reviews mentioned the lack of a ramp.
Value
Open Hotel Makka
8.1Considering the overall experience, guests feel they received good value for their stay.
Al Thill Hotel فندق الظل
8.3Value appreciated in several reviews, though some concerns about quality exist.
Selat Al Bait Hotel
8.4The hotel's pricing has increased slightly, affecting perceived value.
Z Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
8.9Value rated positively, especially for families.
Landmarks
Open Hotel Makka
Al Wardah ParkAl Thill Hotel فندق الظل
حديقة مسجد الرحمةSelat Al Bait Hotel
Suleiman's historic PalaceZ Residence by Dayf - Self-Service Apartments
Al Wardah Park