Lloyd Road Cottage vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.7/10441 reviews

0.48 km (0.30 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

9.5

Rooms are described as clean, renovated, and well-decorated.

Cleanliness

9.5

Generally positive comments about cleanliness and organization.

Location

9.5

Convenient location near the airport, mentioned positively in multiple reviews.

Close alternatives

No close alternative was identified for this preference.

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Lloyd Road Cottage

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.8/1046 reviews

View hotel

Downstairs @38

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.4/10134 reviews

0.96 km (0.60 mi) from original

View hotel

Gardenview Guest House

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.3/1045 reviews

0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.7/10441 reviews

0.48 km (0.30 mi) from original

View hotel

Key differences

Rooms

Downstairs @389.7

Gardenview Guest House9.0

Cleanliness

Lloyd Road Cottage9.6

Gardenview Guest House8.6

Location

Lloyd Road Cottage10.0

Downstairs @389.2

Food & Breakfast

Lloyd Road Cottage9.6

Gardenview Guest House8.6

Value

Lloyd Road Cottage10.0

Downstairs @389.2

Gardenview Guest House amenity advantages

Air conditioningWheelchair accessiblePhysical distancing in dining areas

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth amenity advantages

LaundryAirport shuttleFamily rooms

Detailed comparison

Category	Lloyd Road Cottage	Downstairs @38	Gardenview Guest House	Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth
Guest score	9.8/10	9.4/10	9.3/10	9.7/10
Rooms	9.6 The cottage met all our expectations and was equipped with everything needed.	9.7 Multiple reviews appreciated the quality and comfort of the rooms, noting them as spacious and well-equipped.	9.0 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.5 Rooms are described as clean, renovated, and well-decorated.
Cleanliness	9.6 The cottage was very clean and comfortable.	9.2 Cleanliness was noted positively throughout several reviews, with mentions of the accommodation being very clean and spacious.	8.6 The cleanliness received mixed feedback with some concerns noted.	9.5 Generally positive comments about cleanliness and organization.
Location	10.0 Convenient location close to St Georges hospital.	9.2 The location was frequently mentioned as excellent, with easy access to restaurants and attractions.	10.0 The location was really convenient and nice.	9.5 Convenient location near the airport, mentioned positively in multiple reviews.
Service	10.0 Carol is an excellent, caring, friendly and helpful host.	9.7 Guests highlighted the friendly and accommodating service provided by the staff, which was frequently praised.	9.6 Das Personal war bemüht and was helpful.	10.0 Hostess Jane is frequently praised for her friendliness and attentiveness.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.6 The food was excellent as per the guests' feedback.	9.2 While not extensively mentioned, the quality of breakfast was noted positively.	8.6 Breakfast was described as oversimplified; coffee was occasionally warm.	9.5 Breakfast with a variety of fresh options was positively noted.
Amenities & Facilities	9.6 Delightful amenities within a beautiful garden, though a barbecue area could enhance it.	9.2 Amenities were described as comprehensive, with kitchens fully equipped including thoughtful extras.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.5 Wide range of amenities mentioned, including a lovely garden and pool.
Value	10.0 Great value considering the comfort and location.	9.2 Several guests commented on the value for money they experienced, appreciating the quality relative to cost.	9.5 Good value for money as perceived by the guests.	10.0 Based on the offerings and high-quality service, value perceived as high.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.96 km (0.60 mi)	0.25 km (0.16 mi)	0.48 km (0.30 mi)
Landmarks	Outspan Park	Settlers Park	Outspan Park	Outspan Park
Best suited for	Families	Couples	Couples	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.8/10

Downstairs @38

9.4/10

Gardenview Guest House

9.3/10

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.7/10

Rooms

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The cottage met all our expectations and was equipped with everything needed.

Downstairs @38

9.7

Multiple reviews appreciated the quality and comfort of the rooms, noting them as spacious and well-equipped.

Gardenview Guest House

9.0

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Rooms are described as clean, renovated, and well-decorated.

Cleanliness

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The cottage was very clean and comfortable.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Cleanliness was noted positively throughout several reviews, with mentions of the accommodation being very clean and spacious.

Gardenview Guest House

8.6

The cleanliness received mixed feedback with some concerns noted.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Generally positive comments about cleanliness and organization.

Location

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Convenient location close to St Georges hospital.

Downstairs @38

9.2

The location was frequently mentioned as excellent, with easy access to restaurants and attractions.

Gardenview Guest House

10.0

The location was really convenient and nice.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Convenient location near the airport, mentioned positively in multiple reviews.

Service

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Carol is an excellent, caring, friendly and helpful host.

Downstairs @38

9.7

Guests highlighted the friendly and accommodating service provided by the staff, which was frequently praised.

Gardenview Guest House

9.6

Das Personal war bemüht and was helpful.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

10.0

Hostess Jane is frequently praised for her friendliness and attentiveness.

Sleep & Noise

Lloyd Road Cottage

—

Downstairs @38

—

Gardenview Guest House

—

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

—

Food & Breakfast

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The food was excellent as per the guests' feedback.

Downstairs @38

9.2

While not extensively mentioned, the quality of breakfast was noted positively.

Gardenview Guest House

8.6

Breakfast was described as oversimplified; coffee was occasionally warm.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Breakfast with a variety of fresh options was positively noted.

Amenities & Facilities

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

Delightful amenities within a beautiful garden, though a barbecue area could enhance it.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Amenities were described as comprehensive, with kitchens fully equipped including thoughtful extras.

Gardenview Guest House

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Wide range of amenities mentioned, including a lovely garden and pool.

Value

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Great value considering the comfort and location.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Several guests commented on the value for money they experienced, appreciating the quality relative to cost.

Gardenview Guest House

9.5

Good value for money as perceived by the guests.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

10.0

Based on the offerings and high-quality service, value perceived as high.

Landmarks

Lloyd Road Cottage

Outspan Park

Downstairs @38

Settlers Park

Gardenview Guest House

Outspan Park

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

Outspan Park

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Lloyd Road Cottage

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.8/1046 reviews

View hotel

Downstairs @38

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.4/10134 reviews

0.96 km (0.60 mi) from original

View hotel

Gardenview Guest House

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.3/1045 reviews

0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

Port Elizabeth, ZA

★ 4-star9.7/10441 reviews

0.48 km (0.30 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Lloyd Road Cottage	Downstairs @38	Gardenview Guest House	Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth
Guest score	9.8/10	9.4/10	9.3/10	9.7/10
Rooms	9.6 The cottage met all our expectations and was equipped with everything needed.	9.7 Multiple reviews appreciated the quality and comfort of the rooms, noting them as spacious and well-equipped.	9.0 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.5 Rooms are described as clean, renovated, and well-decorated.
Cleanliness	9.6 The cottage was very clean and comfortable.	9.2 Cleanliness was noted positively throughout several reviews, with mentions of the accommodation being very clean and spacious.	8.6 The cleanliness received mixed feedback with some concerns noted.	9.5 Generally positive comments about cleanliness and organization.
Location	10.0 Convenient location close to St Georges hospital.	9.2 The location was frequently mentioned as excellent, with easy access to restaurants and attractions.	10.0 The location was really convenient and nice.	9.5 Convenient location near the airport, mentioned positively in multiple reviews.
Service	10.0 Carol is an excellent, caring, friendly and helpful host.	9.7 Guests highlighted the friendly and accommodating service provided by the staff, which was frequently praised.	9.6 Das Personal war bemüht and was helpful.	10.0 Hostess Jane is frequently praised for her friendliness and attentiveness.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.6 The food was excellent as per the guests' feedback.	9.2 While not extensively mentioned, the quality of breakfast was noted positively.	8.6 Breakfast was described as oversimplified; coffee was occasionally warm.	9.5 Breakfast with a variety of fresh options was positively noted.
Amenities & Facilities	9.6 Delightful amenities within a beautiful garden, though a barbecue area could enhance it.	9.2 Amenities were described as comprehensive, with kitchens fully equipped including thoughtful extras.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.5 Wide range of amenities mentioned, including a lovely garden and pool.
Value	10.0 Great value considering the comfort and location.	9.2 Several guests commented on the value for money they experienced, appreciating the quality relative to cost.	9.5 Good value for money as perceived by the guests.	10.0 Based on the offerings and high-quality service, value perceived as high.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.96 km (0.60 mi)	0.25 km (0.16 mi)	0.48 km (0.30 mi)
Landmarks	Outspan Park	Settlers Park	Outspan Park	Outspan Park
Best suited for	Families	Couples	Couples	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.8/10

Downstairs @38

9.4/10

Gardenview Guest House

9.3/10

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.7/10

Rooms

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The cottage met all our expectations and was equipped with everything needed.

Downstairs @38

9.7

Multiple reviews appreciated the quality and comfort of the rooms, noting them as spacious and well-equipped.

Gardenview Guest House

9.0

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Rooms are described as clean, renovated, and well-decorated.

Cleanliness

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The cottage was very clean and comfortable.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Cleanliness was noted positively throughout several reviews, with mentions of the accommodation being very clean and spacious.

Gardenview Guest House

8.6

The cleanliness received mixed feedback with some concerns noted.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Generally positive comments about cleanliness and organization.

Location

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Convenient location close to St Georges hospital.

Downstairs @38

9.2

The location was frequently mentioned as excellent, with easy access to restaurants and attractions.

Gardenview Guest House

10.0

The location was really convenient and nice.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Convenient location near the airport, mentioned positively in multiple reviews.

Service

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Carol is an excellent, caring, friendly and helpful host.

Downstairs @38

9.7

Guests highlighted the friendly and accommodating service provided by the staff, which was frequently praised.

Gardenview Guest House

9.6

Das Personal war bemüht and was helpful.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

10.0

Hostess Jane is frequently praised for her friendliness and attentiveness.

Sleep & Noise

Lloyd Road Cottage

—

Downstairs @38

—

Gardenview Guest House

—

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

—

Food & Breakfast

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

The food was excellent as per the guests' feedback.

Downstairs @38

9.2

While not extensively mentioned, the quality of breakfast was noted positively.

Gardenview Guest House

8.6

Breakfast was described as oversimplified; coffee was occasionally warm.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Breakfast with a variety of fresh options was positively noted.

Amenities & Facilities

Lloyd Road Cottage

9.6

Delightful amenities within a beautiful garden, though a barbecue area could enhance it.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Amenities were described as comprehensive, with kitchens fully equipped including thoughtful extras.

Gardenview Guest House

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

9.5

Wide range of amenities mentioned, including a lovely garden and pool.

Value

Lloyd Road Cottage

10.0

Great value considering the comfort and location.

Downstairs @38

9.2

Several guests commented on the value for money they experienced, appreciating the quality relative to cost.

Gardenview Guest House

9.5

Good value for money as perceived by the guests.

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

10.0

Based on the offerings and high-quality service, value perceived as high.

Landmarks

Lloyd Road Cottage

Outspan Park

Downstairs @38

Settlers Park

Gardenview Guest House

Outspan Park

Whistlewood Guesthouse Walmer, Port Eizabeth

Outspan Park