
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Cleanliness
8.4The cleanliness is generally good, though some complaints about thin walls and occasional noise.
Location
9.4The location is praised for its proximity to Sidmouth town and the beach.
Service
9.8Staff were noted as extremely friendly and helpful throughout multiple reviews.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Holmdale House
9.5/10The Nook
8.7/10Hunters Moon Hotel
9.1/10The Woodlands Hotel
9/10Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
9.0Positive: spacious rooms with thoughtful details such as hooks on doors and side tables.
Hunters Moon Hotel
8.3Some rooms noted as comfortable, but there were mentions of tired mattresses.
The Woodlands Hotel
8.8Rooms are generally described as comfortable and well-decorated, despite some mentions of issues with bedding.
Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hunters Moon Hotel
8.4The cleanliness is generally good, though some complaints about thin walls and occasional noise.
The Woodlands Hotel
8.8Most reviews indicate an exceptionally clean and well maintained environment.
Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
9.5Positive: very central, described as an ideal location with delightful surroundings.
Hunters Moon Hotel
9.4The location is praised for its proximity to Sidmouth town and the beach.
The Woodlands Hotel
9.3Many guests highlighted the hotel's prime location, close to the seafront and town.
Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
7.0Negative: arrival/check-in information was confusing; unmarked parking bay and keys plus limited instructions made arrival stressful.
Hunters Moon Hotel
9.8Staff were noted as extremely friendly and helpful throughout multiple reviews.
The Woodlands Hotel
9.3Several guests praised the staff's friendliness and welcoming nature.
Holmdale House
—The Nook
—Hunters Moon Hotel
—The Woodlands Hotel
—Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hunters Moon Hotel
9.4Food quality is consistently praised, especially breakfast options.
The Woodlands Hotel
9.3Guests enjoyed the breakfast and evening meals, highlighting their quality positively.
Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hunters Moon Hotel
8.7Amenities are good, with breakfast choices including vegetarian options.
The Woodlands Hotel
8.8Amenities like the pool table and honesty bar received positive remarks.
Holmdale House
Not enough guest feedbackThe Nook
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hunters Moon Hotel
9.5Many reviews highlight excellent value for money despite minor decor updates needed.
The Woodlands Hotel
8.8Overall satisfaction indicates that guests felt they received good value.
Holmdale House
Landmark data unavailableThe Nook
Tudor CottageHunters Moon Hotel
The ByesThe Woodlands Hotel
Old Hayes