Merlindale vs Similar Hotels

Rooms described as large, well-kitted out, and comfortable.

Rooms and beds repeatedly described as comfortable and quiet; some rooms are slightly aged and one mattress had a noticeable dip that was replaced during the stay.

The rooms are described as comfortable and well-equipped.

Some rooms are appointed well, but concerns about cleanliness.

Overall sentiment is positive, with mentions of lovely and clean properties.

Rooms described as clean and tidy and hotel generally well kept, though one report of a pungent drain smell in the dining room and the property is noted as slightly dated in places.

The reviews indicate that the rooms were clean and well-maintained.

The room was not very clean and had a musty smell.

Great location mentioned for exploring the area.

Quiet hotel set in gardens, pleasant drive from Perth and only a short (≈5 minute) walk to the Hydro — repeatedly described as a good, peaceful location.

Multiple reviews commend the perfect location for exploring the area.

The hotel has sprawling grounds with many activities.

Consistently praised as friendly, welcoming, and attentive hosts.

Majority of reviews praise very friendly, polite, helpful and efficient staff with prompt responses (e.g., mattress change). One review reports incompetent/unresponsive staff, so sentiment is mixed but overall strongly positive.

Numerous positive mentions of friendly and helpful staff.

Friendly and helpful staff, especially the concierge team.

Breakfast and other food options received high praise.

Full Scottish breakfasts and restaurant food receive strong praise, though there are isolated service lapses (running out of milk/croissants) and complaints about extra charges and a drain smell affecting the dining area.

Food quality good, but some found it limited.

Breakfast was poor, and dining experience was disappointing.

Tea, coffee, and shortbread available; well-maintained facilities.

Good on-site parking and access to Crieff Hydro facilities (pool/sauna) praised; restaurant and general facilities noted positively.

Basic amenities available, with some room for improvement noted.

Variety of activities available, including music bingo and horse-riding.

Overall enjoyment suggests good value for the service provided.

Several guests call the hotel good value, but complaints about a £30/night dog charge and being charged for small items (e.g., £7.50 for bread) lower perceived value for some customers.

Overall good value highlighted by several guests.

Prices in restaurants are seen as expensive.