Our pick
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star9.1/10355 reviews
0.49 km (0.30 mi) from original
English
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.2Spacious rooms with a jacuzzi.
Cleanliness
8.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
9.2Very good location, away from mass tourism.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
San Andrés, CO
★ 0-star9/10121 reviews
0.99 km (0.61 mi) from original
Our pick
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star9.1/10355 reviews
0.49 km (0.30 mi) from original
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
San Andrés, CO
★ 0-star8.6/10220 reviews
4.2 km (2.6 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only9.2
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation4.6
Cleanliness
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas8.2
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation4.7
Service
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only9.7
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation9.1
Food & Breakfast
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only9.2
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation3.7
Amenities & Facilities
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only9.2
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation6.7
Value
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only9.2
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation5.6
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation amenity advantages
Business center
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping amenity advantages
Parking
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only amenity advantages
Hot tub/JacuzziLaundry
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas amenity advantages
Spa/wellness center
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.8 km.
Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only: 0.49 km (0.30 mi)
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas: 4.2 km (2.6 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
6.2/10Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
9/10Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.1/10Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.6/10Rooms
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
4.6Issues with room facilities, such as no electricity and broken locks.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.2Spacious rooms with a jacuzzi.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Rooms are described as small and may lack features like suitable charging ports, impacting overall satisfaction.
Cleanliness
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
4.7Rooms were extremely humid, indicating poor cleanliness.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
8.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Some reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, but there are consistency issues due to noise disturbances and minor complaints.
Location
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
8.7The location was a pro.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.2Very good location, away from mass tourism.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7The location is praised for being convenient and peaceful, but it's also noted to be a bit far from some attractions.
Service
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
9.1Standard service, but issues with dinner reservations.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.7Very friendly and helpful staff.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
9.2The service received high praise across multiple reviews, indicating a consistently positive sentiment.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
—Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
—Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
3.7Negative experience regarding food service.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.2Delicious breakfast and cocktails.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Food options received mixed reviews, indicating room for improvement.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
6.7Lack of provided amenities such as towels and remotes.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.2Beautiful pool area and personal whirlpool.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7Positive mentions of amenities like the kayak service and cleanliness, though some areas could improve.
Value
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
5.6Overall dissatisfaction with the value received.
Marysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
—Miraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
9.2Excellent experience for the price.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7The pricing is deemed acceptable in relation to the experience provided, though some items could be better.
Landmarks
Hotel Blue Cove by On vacation
Blue CoveMarysol Lodging Hostel & Camping
Mergulho san AndrésMiraflores Boutique Hotel Adults Only
Blue CoveMangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
La Mansion