Our pick
English
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.8Guests enjoyed the luxurious ambiance and room quality.
Cleanliness
9.8Cleanliness was noted as great by several reviewers.
Location
9.3Location praised for its picturesque setting, though access roads were mentioned as problematic.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
Mooirivier, ZA
★ 5-star9/10218 reviews
28.1 km (17.4 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Hartford House9.8
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout6.5
Cleanliness
Hartford House9.8
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout6.0
Service
Hartford House10.0
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout9.1
Food & Breakfast
Tegwaan's Nest B&B9.9
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout8.6
Amenities & Facilities
Hartford House9.8
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout8.1
Value
Tegwaan's Nest B&B9.8
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout7.0
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout amenity advantages
Sauna
Hartford House amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceLuggage storageMeeting/banquet facilitiesShuttle service (additional charge)
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 24.9 km.
Hartford House: 3.2 km (2.0 mi)
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse: 28.1 km (17.4 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
7.8/10Hartford House
9.5/10Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.5/10Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
9/10Rooms
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
6.5Room quality impacted by dated furnishings and maintenance issues.
Hartford House
9.8Guests enjoyed the luxurious ambiance and room quality.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.3The rooms were described as cozy, comfortable, and clean.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
8.8Rooms were generally seen as comfortable and well-kept.
Cleanliness
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
6.0Noted issues with cleanliness such as sticky cupboards, dusty corners and unclean bathrooms.
Hartford House
9.8Cleanliness was noted as great by several reviewers.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
8.4There were mentions that it was clean but noted some issues with the pool and missing toiletries.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
8.3Occasional mentions of cleanliness; overall positive but noted slight dissatisfaction.
Location
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
9.1Beautiful location, scenic views mentioned frequently.
Hartford House
9.3Location praised for its picturesque setting, though access roads were mentioned as problematic.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.4The cabin's location had a beautiful view and serene environment.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
9.3The location was praised for its beauty and tranquility.
Service
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
9.1Generally friendly staff noted in multiple reviews.
Hartford House
10.0Staff were friendly, helpful, and attentive, contributing positively to the experience.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.9The hosts were described as friendly, hospitable, and went above and beyond to ensure a great experience.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
9.3Staff were described as attentive, friendly, and welcoming.
Sleep & Noise
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
—Hartford House
—Tegwaan's Nest B&B
—Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
—Food & Breakfast
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
8.6Positive feedback on food quality, especially the Xmas lunch.
Hartford House
8.8Food quality received mixed reviews, impacting the overall satisfaction.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.9Breakfast received exceptional praise, with guests complimenting its quality and variety.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
9.3Food was highlighted as exceptional, with high praise across multiple reviews.
Amenities & Facilities
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
8.1Some amenities functioning well, but kitchen equipment and entertainment options need improvement.
Hartford House
9.8Amenities were considered top drawer, but lack of a spa was a noted downside.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.4Amenities such as the electric blanket and beautiful scenery were positively noted.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
8.8Facilities mentioned positively, with notable food quality.
Value
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
7.0Concerns raised about the cost versus quality of stay due to maintenance issues.
Hartford House
8.8Concerns were raised regarding the value of food offered, impacting perception of overall value.
Tegwaan's Nest B&B
9.8Guests felt they received great value for the services provided.
Cleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
8.8Mixed feelings about pricing, especially during peak times.
Landmarks
First Group Midlands Saddle and Trout
No landmark signals returnedHartford House
No landmark signals returnedTegwaan's Nest B&B
Rosetta parkCleopatra Mountain Farmhouse
No landmark signals returned