Our pick
The Garden Rooms at Tannery House
Bakewell, GB
★ 0-star8.9/10547 reviews
0.08 km (0.05 mi) from original
English
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.3Some rooms reported as lovely, but others noted issues with heating and decor.
Cleanliness
7.9Several mentions of tired decor, cobwebs, and a mouldy bathroom indicate cleanliness issues.
Location
9.9Repeated praise for the excellent central location.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
Bakewell, GB
★ 4-star8.8/102,827 reviews
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Bakewell, GB
★ 3-star8.2/107 reviews
0.39 km (0.24 mi) from original
Our pick
The Garden Rooms at Tannery House
Bakewell, GB
★ 0-star8.9/10547 reviews
0.08 km (0.05 mi) from original
Key differences
Location
The Garden Rooms at Tannery House9.9
Bagshaw Hall9.1
Food & Breakfast
The Garden Rooms at Tannery House9.4
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group8.0
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group amenity advantages
RestaurantRoom serviceWheelchair accessibleMeeting/banquet facilitiesKid meals
Bagshaw Hall amenity advantages
Breakfast in the roomElectric vehicle charging station
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.8/10Bagshaw Hall
8.6/10The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
8.2/10The Garden Rooms at Tannery House
8.9/10Rooms
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.4Rooms were nicely decorated but some found the bed small.
Bagshaw Hall
8.6Rooms were described as cozy and well-appointed with some mentions of comfort issues.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
8.3Some rooms reported as lovely, but others noted issues with heating and decor.
Cleanliness
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.0Shower not particularly clean.
Bagshaw Hall
7.6One review mentioned that kitchen items were not very clean prior to use.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
7.9Several mentions of tired decor, cobwebs, and a mouldy bathroom indicate cleanliness issues.
Location
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
9.4Location was excellent.
Bagshaw Hall
9.1Guests frequently highlighted the great location for accessing the town and surrounding areas.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
9.9Repeated praise for the excellent central location.
Service
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
9.4Extremely friendly, welcoming and helpful staff.
Bagshaw Hall
9.6Multiple reviews praised the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
9.3Mostly positive experiences but some frustration regarding the check-in process.
Sleep & Noise
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
—Bagshaw Hall
—The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
—The Garden Rooms at Tannery House
—Food & Breakfast
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.0Breakfast service was slow and had issues.
Bagshaw Hall
8.1Breakfast was noted as prompt and tasty, contributing positively.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
9.4Breakfast received high praise from multiple reviews.
Amenities & Facilities
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.9Included everything we could need for a night's stay.
Bagshaw Hall
8.6Guests appreciated the well-refurbished nature of the property and facilities offered.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
8.8Good amenities reported, though some issues with the bathroom.
Value
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.9Good value for money.
Bagshaw Hall
8.6General sentiment regarding value for money was positive.
The Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Not enough guest feedbackThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
8.8Value perceived as reasonable given the overall experience.
Landmarks
The Rutland Arms Hotel, Bakewell, Derbyshire - The Coaching Inn Group
War MemorialBagshaw Hall
War MemorialThe Artists Loft - a converted from a Grade II Listed 17th Century building
Bakewell CastleThe Garden Rooms at Tannery House
War Memorial