Our pick
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star7.3/10197 reviews
0.47 km (0.29 mi) from original
English
Hotel Portobelo beach vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
7.3Rooms are described as cozy and well-equipped, but there were mentions of issues like late cleaning.
Service
8.3Reviews generally express positive feelings towards staff attentiveness, despite some incidents of poor service.
Value
7.8Many guests feel the overall value is good considering the price.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
San Andrés, CO
★ 3-star6.6/10101 reviews
0.07 km (0.04 mi) from original
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
San Andrés, CO
★ 3-star6.9/1084 reviews
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
Our pick
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star7.3/10197 reviews
0.47 km (0.29 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Hotel Portobelo beach
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Cleanliness6.2
Amenities & Facilities6.8
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Location8.8
Amenities & Facilities6.6
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Cleanliness5.8
Location9.2
Amenities & Facilities7.2
Key differences
Rooms
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas7.3
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center6.6
Cleanliness
Hotel Portobelo beach6.2
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center4.0
Location
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia9.2
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas7.9
Service
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia8.8
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center6.6
Food & Breakfast
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas8.9
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia4.5
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia7.2
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas5.9
Value
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas7.8
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia5.9
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia amenity advantages
Parking
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas amenity advantages
Fitness center
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel Portobelo beach
7.1/10Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
6.6/10Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
6.9/10Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.3/10Rooms
Hotel Portobelo beach
6.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
6.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
6.8Rooms are described as spacious and comfortable with good beds by some guests, but others reported noisy street-facing rooms, faulty/dirty air conditioning and dated decor.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.3Rooms are described as cozy and well-equipped, but there were mentions of issues like late cleaning.
Cleanliness
Hotel Portobelo beach
6.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
4.0Lencería del baño necesita renovación y faltó limpieza diaria en la habitación.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
5.8Mixed reports: some guests describe rooms as 'siempre impecable', while others report dirty/musty AC, very yellow/old towels and lingering odors.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
4.9Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness, such as dirty sheets and the pool being out of service.
Location
Hotel Portobelo beach
8.3La cercanía a la playa es excelente.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
8.8La ubicación fue descrita como perfecta.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
9.2Consistently praised across reviews for very good/ideal location.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.9The location is praised for being centrally located, although some reviews mention it may not be ideal for older guests.
Service
Hotel Portobelo beach
8.2La atención del personal del hotel son muy amables.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
6.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
8.8Generally attentive staff noted in several reviews ('funcionarios atenciosos', 'Muy buena atención'), but there are specific complaints about reception being poco amable and not resolving issues.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
8.3Reviews generally express positive feelings towards staff attentiveness, despite some incidents of poor service.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel Portobelo beach
—Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
—Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
—Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel Portobelo beach
6.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
7.0Desayuno bueno aunque poco variado.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
4.5Frequently criticized: breakfast often described as poor or lacking variety, and dinner/menu repetitive; suggestions for more fruit/juice/variants.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
8.9The food consistently receives high praise for quality and variety.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Portobelo beach
6.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
6.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
7.2Pool appreciated but with limited hours; cafeteria closes early; limited toiletries supplied; WiFi problems in rooms reported; overall mixed but functional amenities.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
5.9Amenities were a mixed bag; although the pool is appreciated, other amenities like the gym were out of order.
Value
Hotel Portobelo beach
6.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Portobelo Convention Center
6.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
5.9Mixed perceptions: some guests found good price-quality balance, while others felt the price was high for the condition of the assigned room.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.8Many guests feel the overall value is good considering the price.
Landmarks
Hotel Portobelo beach
Man of war treeHotel Portobelo Convention Center
Porto finoHotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
Man of war treeHotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
Cañon de Morgan