
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.7Rooms are charming, but some small issues noted with space.
Cleanliness
9.2Generally clean based on positive mentions, but insights suggest minor issues.
Location
10.0Excellent location with close access to attractions.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Saint Andrews, CA
0.37 km (0.23 mi) from original

Saint Andrews, CA
0.28 km (0.18 mi) from original

Kennedy House
8.3/10St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4/10The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9/10Treadwell Inn
9.5/10Kennedy House
7.6Several mentions of dated rooms and inconsistent amenities.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
7.9Rooms reported as dated and in need of updates.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.7Mixed sentiment; some rooms had issues but overall comfort was highlighted.
Treadwell Inn
8.7Rooms are charming, but some small issues noted with space.
Kennedy House
7.7Some comments indicate issues with old, stained carpets and other cleanliness concerns.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
7.9The cleanliness was a concern with reports of dirty rooms and mold.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
7.7Multiple mentions of dirty sheets and overall cleanliness issues.
Treadwell Inn
9.2Generally clean based on positive mentions, but insights suggest minor issues.
Kennedy House
9.2Reviews frequently highlight the perfect central location.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
9.4Consistently praised for a beautiful and convenient location.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9.6Conveniently located near attractions, positively mentioned in several reviews.
Treadwell Inn
10.0Excellent location with close access to attractions.
Kennedy House
9.1Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
9.4Staff were frequently mentioned as friendly and helpful.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
10.0Hosts are described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.
Treadwell Inn
10.0Overall positive mentions of friendly and attentive staff.
Kennedy House
—St Andrews Inn & Suites
—The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
—Treadwell Inn
—Kennedy House
8.2Restaurant meals received mixed feedback but generally considered decent.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
6.9Limited breakfast selection and negative comments on free donuts.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.1Limited options for food and drinks were mentioned by guests.
Treadwell Inn
9.7Highly rated for the breakfast and restaurant quality.
Kennedy House
8.2Amenities like the bar and entertainment were positively noted, but limited options such as no breakfast impacted the score.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4Amenities like the pool received mixed reviews but overall acceptable.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.6Some amenities were lacking, such as limited breakfast offerings and room appliances.
Treadwell Inn
9.2Amenities were sufficient but could be improved, such as lack of tea-making facilities.
Kennedy House
8.1Most reviews express that the hotel provides good value for the price.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4Some reviews felt the price was high given the condition of the rooms.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9.7Overall guests felt it provided good value for the price.
Treadwell Inn
9.6Good value based on overall feedback but some concerns about specific pricing.
Kennedy House
Canadian War MemorialSt Andrews Inn & Suites
Drug Store MuralThe Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
Drug Store MuralTreadwell Inn
Hardware Store Mural