
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
7.6Some rooms were cold and the decor felt drab.
Cleanliness
7.6Room cleanliness was subpar, noted issues with cobwebs and dust.
Service
9.1Most reviews highlighted friendly and helpful staff.




Hartlepool, GB
8.8 km (5.5 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 8.4 km.
The Douglas Hotel: 0.45 km (0.28 mi)
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel: 8.8 km (5.5 mi)
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
7.4/10The Douglas Hotel
7.8/10The Marine Hotel
8.4/10Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
8.2/10Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
6.8Concerns about room size and cold conditions, but praised for general feel.
The Douglas Hotel
6.5Issues like cold rooms and poor maintenance led to low satisfaction.
The Marine Hotel
7.6Some rooms were cold and the decor felt drab.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
6.8Several guests reported small or dated rooms, low water pressure, lumpy beds and some maintenance issues (broken shower, tiny windows); room comfort is a clear area for improvement.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
6.3Issues with cleanliness, including cold breakfast, stains, and lack of hot water.
The Douglas Hotel
5.5Numerous mentions of dirt, filth, and bedbugs indicate a severe cleanliness issue.
The Marine Hotel
7.6Room cleanliness was subpar, noted issues with cobwebs and dust.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
7.8Generally described as clean in parts (breakfast room, some rooms) but several comments note tired decor, smells from a toilet area and need for maintenance, so cleanliness is slightly below average due to occasional odour and visible wear.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
8.8Positive mentions of the hotel's central location.
The Douglas Hotel
10.0Positive comments on location, regarded as convenient.
The Marine Hotel
8.6Good location near beach and city highlights.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
8.6Multiple reviewers highlight a pleasant, quiet, green setting and good gardens/parking; one note that it is fairly remote and can host weddings, but overall location is a strong positive.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
8.3Staff are frequently mentioned as helpful and friendly, despite some shortages.
The Douglas Hotel
8.0Customers reported rude staff and poor service, highlighting dissatisfaction.
The Marine Hotel
9.1Most reviews highlighted friendly and helpful staff.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
9.2Consistently praised: friendly, helpful and accommodating staff (including specific praise for a waitress and accommodation of dietary needs), warm welcome and good service in dining areas.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
—The Douglas Hotel
—The Marine Hotel
—Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
—Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
5.8Breakfast experiences varied from lukewarm to cold, and presentation lacked quality.
The Douglas Hotel
5.5Multiple complaints about food quality indicate poor experiences.
The Marine Hotel
9.1Breakfast and other meals received high praise for quality.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
9.2Very strong consensus that evening meals and breakfast are excellent—well presented, tasty and with good choices—one of the hotel's standout features.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
7.3Basic amenities met expectations, though some areas for improvement noted.
The Douglas Hotel
7.5Lack of promised amenities and disrepair reported by guests.
The Marine Hotel
8.1Basic amenities were mentioned; a bit lacking in modern features.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
8.4Good on amenities mentioned: restaurant/bar, parking, pet-friendly facilities and pleasant gardens; wedding-venue activity can impact ambience at times.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
7.7Generally good value relative to location but noted areas lacked value.
The Douglas Hotel
9.4Some guests felt the price was acceptable, but many reported needing better quality.
The Marine Hotel
8.6Good value noted, particularly for food and breakfast.
Hardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
8.0Generally considered good value by reviewers (explicit praise for value and adequacy for short stays), though some feel the property needs investment which tempers perceived value slightly.
Best Western The Grand Hotel Hartlepool
Hartlepool School for Girls EntranceThe Douglas Hotel
Hartlepool School for Girls EntranceThe Marine Hotel
Seaton Carew Outdoor Leisure ParkHardwicke Hall Manor Hotel
Welfare Park