Our pick
Rivers Edge Retreat
Clearwater, CA
★ 0-star9/10181 reviews
0.36 km (0.22 mi) from original
English
Stoneshire Guesthouse vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.7Rooms were comfortable and well-furnished, though some mentioned varied conditions.
Cleanliness
9.2The property is spotless and has attention to detail.
Location
9.7Great location with beautiful river views and accessibility.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
Clearwater, CA
★ 3-star7.5/10788 reviews
0.70 km (0.44 mi) from original
Our pick
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
Clearwater, CA
★ 3-star7.3/101,370 reviews
1.1 km (0.67 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Stoneshire Guesthouse9.0
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat6.8
Cleanliness
Stoneshire Guesthouse9.2
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground5.2
Location
Rivers Edge Retreat9.7
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat7.9
Service
Stoneshire Guesthouse9.5
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat7.8
Food & Breakfast
Rivers Edge Retreat9.2
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat6.4
Amenities & Facilities
Stoneshire Guesthouse9.3
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground6.2
Value
Stoneshire Guesthouse8.7
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat7.3
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessibleSkiing
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat amenity advantages
RestaurantRoom serviceLaundryLuggage storageAirport shuttle
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.1/10Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
7.5/10Rivers Edge Retreat
9/10Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
7.3/10Rooms
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.0Spacious and well-equipped units, though some mention noise issues.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
7.7Generally comfortable but some rooms described as needing repairs.
Rivers Edge Retreat
8.7Rooms were comfortable and well-furnished, though some mentioned varied conditions.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
6.8Rooms were described as clean but some issues with temperature and maintenance.
Cleanliness
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.2Reviews highlight the place as very clean and well-kept.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
5.2Some reviews mention issues with cleanliness, including stained towels and sheets.
Rivers Edge Retreat
9.2The property is spotless and has attention to detail.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
6.9Mixed reviews on cleanliness with some guests mentioning stained bedding and unclean sheets.
Location
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.2The surrounding area is often noted as charming and ideal for visiting.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
8.2The location is described as quiet and near the lake, which is appreciated by guests.
Rivers Edge Retreat
9.7Great location with beautiful river views and accessibility.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
7.9Conveniently located near attractions, though some find it slightly remote for breakfast options.
Service
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.5Positive mentions of good communication and helpfulness from the host.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
8.7Most reviews commend the professional staff and helpful service.
Rivers Edge Retreat
9.2The hosts were friendly and provided excellent recommendations.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
7.8Many guests praised the staff for being friendly and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise
Stoneshire Guesthouse
—Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
—Rivers Edge Retreat
—Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
—Food & Breakfast
Stoneshire Guesthouse
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
7.7Some good mentions about nearby restaurants and food quality.
Rivers Edge Retreat
9.2No specific comments, assumed satisfactory as only dining recommendations were mentioned.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
6.4Breakfast options were frequently criticized as minimal and inadequate.
Amenities & Facilities
Stoneshire Guesthouse
9.3Well-equipped kitchen and comfortable living space are frequently praised.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
6.2Limited kitchen utensils noted, affecting the overall experience.
Rivers Edge Retreat
8.2Some mentioned missing items like better kitchenware.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
7.9Basic amenities were available, though some reported missing items like hairdryers.
Value
Stoneshire Guesthouse
8.7General satisfaction with what is provided for the price.
Jasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
8.2Guests feel they received good value considering location and experience.
Rivers Edge Retreat
8.7Good value given location, but some noted it could be better.
Hotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
7.3Some guests found it good value but expressed concerns about certain amenities.
Landmarks
Stoneshire Guesthouse
Dutch Lake Beach ParkJasper Way Inn Resort & Campground
Dutch Lake Beach ParkRivers Edge Retreat
Dutch Lake Beach ParkHotel Civilia Lakeside by Civilia Golf Retreat
Dutch Lake Beach Park