
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.9Large room with good privacy, but some areas are a bit worn.
Cleanliness
8.5A bit worn out especially the bath area and the rooms.
Location
9.5Convenient access to onsen town, though returning involves a steep walk.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Bosenkan
8/10Yunoshimakan
9.1/10Izumi-so
8.9/10Suimeikan
8.7/10Bosenkan
7.5Rooms are spacious and futon/mattress comfort noted, but several guests cited dated decor, stains, occasional odors, a broken fridge and mixed maintenance.
Yunoshimakan
8.9Large room with good privacy, but some areas are a bit worn.
Izumi-so
8.9The rooms were described as spacious and comfortable with a nice traditional feel.
Suimeikan
8.6Rooms are clean and spacious, but some amenities like bath towers are insufficient.
Bosenkan
7.0Several guests mentioned stains, moldy smell in corridors, old towels and occasional odors in rooms, indicating below‑average cleanliness in places.
Yunoshimakan
8.5A bit worn out especially the bath area and the rooms.
Izumi-so
7.9There were mentions of mold in the onsen area, indicating cleanliness issues.
Suimeikan
8.1The toilet is old and tiny, and there are mentions of an unpleasant smell from the heating.
Bosenkan
8.0Good scenic location and attractive garden; however some guests noted remoteness, taxi reliance and train noise for rooms facing the line.
Yunoshimakan
9.5Convenient access to onsen town, though returning involves a steep walk.
Izumi-so
8.9The location is convenient and close to the station, making it easy to walk.
Suimeikan
9.1The location is very close to the train station, making it convenient for guests.
Bosenkan
9.0Repeated praise for staff—friendly, helpful, polite (including foreign staff with good Japanese)—service is a strong point across reviews.
Yunoshimakan
9.9Outstanding staff, warm welcome, and attentive service.
Izumi-so
9.4Guests consistently praised the friendly and helpful nature of the staff.
Suimeikan
9.1Service was generally positive, with friendly staff in dining and onsen areas, though one instance of unfriendliness was noted.
Bosenkan
—Yunoshimakan
—Izumi-so
—Suimeikan
—Bosenkan
8.0Many guests praised kaiseki/set meals, dinner and breakfast; a minority found meals bland or disappointing, yielding an overall positive but mixed score.
Yunoshimakan
9.5Amazing breakfast and good dinner options.
Izumi-so
8.9Breakfast and dinner were noted as excellent quality, positively impacting guest satisfaction.
Suimeikan
8.8Food is generally well received, with a variety of options for both dinner and breakfast.
Bosenkan
7.5Onsen is appreciated by many but criticized by some as small/poorly arranged; limited dryers, steep stairs to baths and some noisy/old equipment reduce the score.
Yunoshimakan
8.5Beautiful outdoor onsens, but the hotel is in need of redecoration.
Izumi-so
8.9Onsens available, with both indoor and outdoor options, enhancing the guest experience.
Suimeikan
8.8Onsen facilities are praised, though crowds can affect experience.
Bosenkan
8.5Multiple guests commented the stay felt like good value or a bargain for the price, praising meals and service relative to cost.
Yunoshimakan
8.4Pricey, but the experiences justify the costs.
Izumi-so
8.9Overall satisfaction with the offerings suggests good value for the experience.
Suimeikan
8.6Dinner is wonderful and the hotel offers a good range of services.
Bosenkan
しらさぎ緑地公園1Yunoshimakan
湯之島館Izumi-so
しらさぎ緑地公園1Suimeikan
しらさぎ緑地公園2