
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.4Accommodations were described as spacious, comfortable and well-equipped.
Cleanliness
9.5Rooms were described as very clean and well maintained, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
10.0The location is perfect, very close to Silent Beach and other attractions.




The compared hotels differ by 0.82 km.
Amour Surf: 0.18 km (0.11 mi)
Tanzanite place: 1.0 km (0.62 mi)
Aga Surf View
9.6/10Amour Surf
9/10Shadow Surf Bay
9.7/10Tanzanite place
9.5/10Aga Surf View
9.7Rooms were reported as comfortable and well-maintained.
Amour Surf
9.0The room was comfortable.
Shadow Surf Bay
9.4Accommodations were described as spacious, comfortable and well-equipped.
Tanzanite place
9.7Rooms are noted as spacious and comfortable.
Aga Surf View
8.7Some reviews mention issues with cleanliness such as dead flies in the pool.
Amour Surf
8.1While the room was generally clean, there was a mention of issues with the wifi not working.
Shadow Surf Bay
9.5Rooms were described as very clean and well maintained, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Tanzanite place
8.7Mixed sentiments about cleanliness, with some mentions of opportunities for improvement.
Aga Surf View
10.0Consistently praised for being in a beautiful and convenient location.
Amour Surf
9.1Perfect location just steps away from the beaches.
Shadow Surf Bay
10.0The location is perfect, very close to Silent Beach and other attractions.
Tanzanite place
9.7Positive feedback on the proximity to Silent Beach.
Aga Surf View
9.2Mixed sentiments, with some positive experiences but mention of an unhelpful manager.
Amour Surf
9.6The host was very welcoming and attentive.
Shadow Surf Bay
9.9Guests repeatedly noted the friendly and helpful nature of the hosts.
Tanzanite place
9.7Guests mention the hosts being very kind and helpful.
Aga Surf View
—Amour Surf
—Shadow Surf Bay
—Tanzanite place
—Aga Surf View
10.0Exceptional food quality praised across multiple reviews.
Amour Surf
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Shadow Surf Bay
10.0Guests loved the variety and quality of the breakfasts provided.
Tanzanite place
9.2Breakfast was mentioned as tasty, although it wasn't detailed in some reviews.
Aga Surf View
9.7Facilities were described as great, with a lovely pool and gardens.
Amour Surf
9.1The rooftop with great views is a highlight.
Shadow Surf Bay
9.4Amenities such as balconies and air conditioning were specifically praised.
Tanzanite place
9.2Amenities such as air conditioning and kitchen facilities are positively mentioned.
Aga Surf View
9.7General sentiment indicates good quality for the price.
Amour Surf
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Shadow Surf Bay
9.4Guests felt they received good value for the price paid.
Tanzanite place
9.7Guests find the value for money to be excellent.
Aga Surf View
Mawella beachAmour Surf
Mawella beachShadow Surf Bay
Mawella beachTanzanite place
War Heroes' Monument