
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Cleanliness
9.2The room was comfortable and clean; all staff were exceptional. Overall cleanliness appeared to be high.
Location
9.4Good location for visiting Settle, close to the Yorkshire Dales and town centre.
Service
9.7Staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Settle, GB
1.7 km (1.1 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The Craven Arms
9.1/10The Golden Lion at Settle
8.9/10The Harts Head
9.2/10The Craven Arms
9.1Rooms reported as comfortable and well-appointed by many guests.
The Golden Lion at Settle
9.1Rooms recently revamped and highly valued by guests.
The Harts Head
8.2Some guests noted that rooms could feel cold upon arrival or were not what they expected.
The Craven Arms
9.1Overall feedback indicates cleanliness was a strong point throughout various reviews.
The Golden Lion at Settle
8.2Mixed sentiments; some issues noted regarding public facilities.
The Harts Head
9.2The room was comfortable and clean; all staff were exceptional. Overall cleanliness appeared to be high.
The Craven Arms
9.1Many guests appreciated the idyllic location and nearby attractions.
The Golden Lion at Settle
9.2Centrally located; praised by multiple reviews.
The Harts Head
9.4Good location for visiting Settle, close to the Yorkshire Dales and town centre.
The Craven Arms
9.3Multiple reviews highlight the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff.
The Golden Lion at Settle
9.2Overall, staff were friendly and accommodating, though some negative experiences reported.
The Harts Head
9.7Staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
The Craven Arms
—The Golden Lion at Settle
—The Harts Head
—The Craven Arms
9.3Food quality received high praise, particularly the breakfast and restaurant meals.
The Golden Lion at Settle
9.2Food quality and breakfast selection received high praise.
The Harts Head
9.7Food was consistently noted as delicious, with a variety of options.
The Craven Arms
9.2Amenities were generally well-reviewed, contributing positively to the experience.
The Golden Lion at Settle
9.2Good amenities, with attention to detail like coffee machines and snacks.
The Harts Head
9.2Great extra touches like complimentary water and juice in rooms.
The Craven Arms
8.8Some reviews mentioned the pricing as slightly high for certain offerings.
The Golden Lion at Settle
8.1Some opinions on high prices for certain meals, affecting perceived value.
The Harts Head
8.9Overall good value, particularly for breakfast and dining options.
The Craven Arms
1597-98 Plague StoneThe Golden Lion at Settle
Birthplace of Benjamin WaughThe Harts Head
Low Moo