Stableside Hostel at York Racecourse vs Similar Hotels

Mixed to negative: many comments about small/cramped rooms, some noisy rooms/extension, basic accommodation and occasional maintenance issues (no shelf, awkward kettle placement, lack of en-suite for some).

Some negative feedback on bed comfort and maintenance, affecting overall room quality.

Mixed reviews; some rooms were described as comfortable while others had issues with mattress quality.

Room was small and layout not well thought out, but clean.

Consistently praised: very clean showers/toilets and generally tidy rooms. A few reports of maintenance/cleaning issues (one mention of poor cleaning and some broken showers).

Many complaints regarding cleanliness, including dirty rooms and unmaintained bathrooms.

Several reviews mentioned clean rooms; however, one reviewer noted issues with beds and cleanliness of sheets.

Room was dusty, not what you’d expect for the amount we paid.

Excellent location in a pleasant setting near the racecourse, good bus links to the centre and convenient parking; not right in the city centre but well placed for visitors.

Location near York center was appreciated, though some noted noise issues.

Positive feedback regarding the convenience of location to city center.

Great location, 10-minute walk into the main part of York.

Very positive across reviews: staff described as welcoming, charming, friendly and helpful, especially noted for being dog-friendly and accommodating families.

Staff received high praise for being friendly and helpful.

Consistently praised across multiple reviews for being friendly and helpful.

Staff was friendly and attentive. Reception staff welcoming.

Mostly positive: breakfast frequently described as excellent/fantastic, with a small number of practical suggestions (buffet heating/serving improvements).

Food quality and breakfast were well-received, enhancing the dining experience.

Breakfast and dining options received high praise in several reviews.

Breakfast was nice with lots of choices.

Mixed: positives include free secure parking and dog-friendly policies; negatives include communal shower/WC in some cases, limited in-room facilities and lack of kitchenette or easy tea/coffee access in some rooms.

Amenities such as the pool and breakfast were highlighted positively, but some described them as small.

Good amenities mentioned, such as a well-stocked bar and breakfast options.

Nice bar area and useful spacious dining area.

Strongly positive: several reviewers noted very good/excellent value and reasonable dog supplements — good option for families and budget stays.

Mixed feelings on value for price, though some guests enjoyed their stay.

Good value mentioned relative to quality, with some concerns about specific amenities.

Not quite as expected given the room conditions.