
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.3Some reviews mention the rooms being dated but overall clean and cozy.
Cleanliness
9.3Many reviews highlight the hotel's cleanliness with phrases such as 'very clean room' and 'spotlessly clean'.
Location
9.3Several reviews praise the hotel's great location, being close to the seafront and town.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Whitby, GB
8.2 km (5.1 mi) from original


The compared hotels differ by 4.0 km.
The Forge: 6.9 km (4.3 mi)
Saxonville Hotel: 10.9 km (6.8 mi)
Horseshoe Hotel
7.7/10Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
8/10The Forge
8.8/10Saxonville Hotel
9/10Horseshoe Hotel
6.5Rooms were very tired and need some refurbishment.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
7.5Rooms varied; some were comfortable, while others needed maintenance.
The Forge
8.6Rooms were generally described as comfortable and tidy, with some slight issues mentioned regarding mattress quality.
Saxonville Hotel
8.3Some reviews mention the rooms being dated but overall clean and cozy.
Horseshoe Hotel
6.5Room not to the standard we expected grubby in places.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
7.5Some guests reported issues with dampness and cleanliness in their rooms.
The Forge
8.6General sentiment was positive about cleanliness, but some issues noted like a rusty toilet holder which slightly impacted perception.
Saxonville Hotel
9.3Many reviews highlight the hotel's cleanliness with phrases such as 'very clean room' and 'spotlessly clean'.
Horseshoe Hotel
9.0Lovely location, picturesque setting with great views.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
8.5Great location not too far from the center.
The Forge
8.9Multiple reviews highlighted the convenient and appealing location of the hotel.
Saxonville Hotel
9.3Several reviews praise the hotel's great location, being close to the seafront and town.
Horseshoe Hotel
8.5The staff were excellent and friendly; always attentive.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
8.5Staff were described as helpful and friendly, though limited during check-in.
The Forge
9.1Staff were consistently described as friendly and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Saxonville Hotel
9.3Numerous mentions of friendly and professional staff contribute to a positive sentiment.
Horseshoe Hotel
—Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
—The Forge
—Saxonville Hotel
—Horseshoe Hotel
9.0Food was exceptional and well-catered, with great meal options.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
8.5Breakfast received high praise, but portion sizes for dinner were considered small.
The Forge
9.1Food quality was frequently praised, with several reviews highlighting excellent breakfast and dinner options.
Saxonville Hotel
9.3Breakfast offerings received high praise in multiple reviews.
Horseshoe Hotel
7.0Poor amenities reported, but overall potential once updated.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
8.0Amenities are generally good, though Wi-Fi could be improved.
The Forge
8.6Amenities were generally well-received, although specific amenities were not heavily detailed.
Saxonville Hotel
8.8Amenities like breakfast and parking are praised, contributing positively to the experience.
Horseshoe Hotel
7.4Value considered, but overpriced given current state of the rooms.
Dunsley Hall Country House Hotel
7.5Some found the price too high for the service and room quality offered.
The Forge
8.6Value perceived positively in relation to the overall experience, breakfast quality, and hotel costs.
Saxonville Hotel
8.8Many reviews mention that the hotel provides good value for the prices charged.
Horseshoe Hotel
Egton ManorDunsley Hall Country House Hotel
Sneaton Castle CentreThe Forge
Eskdale ChapelSaxonville Hotel
Crow's Nest