APA Hotel & Resort Nishishinjuku Gochome Ekimae Tower - Formerly APA Hotel & Resort Nishishinjuku Gochome Eki Tower vs Similar Hotels

Small room sizes and issues with temperature control were mentioned.

Rooms were mostly described as small and lacking in storage, which affected the overall perception.

Frequently reported as very small and cramped (especially family rooms); some noise/soundproofing issues. Bathrooms functional but space is limited.

Several reviews noted small room sizes as a drawback.

Several reviews noted issues like small room sizes and temperature control, but overall cleanliness was acceptable.

Overall cleanliness of the hotel was appreciated in multiple reviews, contributing to a satisfactory experience.

Mostly praised as very clean across reviews; a few mentions of room odor and visible dirty tiles that suggest occasional lapses.

Reviews indicate rooms were clean and staff friendly.

Excellent location noted in multiple reviews, very convenient for transport links.

Guests favored the quiet yet accessible location, away from the hustle and bustle.

Consistently highlighted as excellent — close to metro/station, convenient for Shinjuku and Fuji hikers, many guests cite the location as a key benefit.

Proximity to Shinjuku station and quiet area received positive mentions.

Standard quality for this hotel tier, but some reviews mentioned long check-in times and language barriers.

Some guests mentioned unhelpful staff, impacting the service score.

Staff repeatedly described as friendly, helpful and accommodating (e.g., sending forgotten passports); isolated comments about hurried explanations at check-in.

Staff were described as helpful and polite in multiple reviews.

Breakfast received positive feedback, though some felt it could be improved.

Bakery and restaurant offerings were positively noted, enhancing the food and beverage experience.

Breakfast is often praised (variety/quality for many), but several guests report limited variety, small breakfast room, high price or poor quality in isolated cases.

Breakfast was mentioned positively; however, breakfast areas were noted as small.

The onsen and convenience stores nearby were highly appreciated.

Amenities like the bakery and lobby space were enjoyed, adding to the overall experience.

Mixed: room microwaves and basic facilities are positives, but laundry closure, no onsen and partial allergy labeling for breakfast are noted drawbacks.

Convenient amenities including a 7-eleven and toiletries.

Some guests felt the prices were not justified based on room sizes and amenities.

Balancing the high cost with small room size led to a perception of less value for money.

Many guests call it good value for the price; a few mention slightly high pricing or that breakfast adds cost, so value is generally positive but not uniform.

Mixed sentiments on price versus room size and quality.