
The Capital Melrose
Johannesburg, ZA
1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Johannesburg, ZA
1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original
Cleanliness
6.9Several complaints about dirtiness, including dirty carpets and stains.
Location
9.9Centrally located with easy access to shopping and dining.
Service
9.9Staff generally received high praise for their friendliness and helpfulness.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Johannesburg, ZA
1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original

Johannesburg, ZA
5.0 km (3.1 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 3.3 km.
The Capital Melrose: 1.8 km (1.1 mi)
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton: 5.0 km (3.1 mi)
Waverley Guest House
8.9/10La Orchard Hotel
6.8/10The Capital Melrose
8.8/10Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
7/10Waverley Guest House
8.9Room quality generally acceptable except for cleanliness issues.
La Orchard Hotel
4.0Generally negative: reports of old furniture, uncomfortable beds (felt springs), torn/old towels, blocked drains, smelly fridge, and rooms that did not match online descriptions.
The Capital Melrose
8.4Mixed feedback; some experienced small rooms or apartment-like feel.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
6.4Reviews indicated various issues with room conditions, like cold temperatures and no hot water.
Waverley Guest House
6.5The room had mice issues and the fridge in the kitchen needed cleaning.
La Orchard Hotel
3.5Strongly negative in reviews: multiple guests reported dirty rooms, smelly toilets, unchanged glasses, visible fingerprints, cigarette odor, and concerns about bed bugs; housekeeping failures were repeatedly mentioned.
The Capital Melrose
6.9Several complaints about dirtiness, including dirty carpets and stains.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
6.0Multiple reviews mention issues with cleanliness, such as torn sheets and dirty showers.
Waverley Guest House
9.5Enjoyable location with the ability to use the kitchen and space.
La Orchard Hotel
10.0Consistently positive: multiple reviews mention excellent location (well situated for work/projects, near malls) and several guests explicitly listed location as a pro.
The Capital Melrose
9.9Centrally located with easy access to shopping and dining.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
8.0Guests appreciated the location for its peace and tranquility.
Waverley Guest House
10.0The staff took action after complaints, providing rattex.
La Orchard Hotel
9.0Mixed but often praised for friendliness: several guests called staff kind or friendly and noted staff tried to help. Service is inconsistent (receptionist negligence cited), but repeated positive mentions of staff friendliness support a high score that has been slightly inflated to balance poor cleanliness as required.
The Capital Melrose
9.9Staff generally received high praise for their friendliness and helpfulness.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
7.4Some guests noted that the staff were friendly, but others expressed rudeness and unprofessionalism.
Waverley Guest House
—La Orchard Hotel
—The Capital Melrose
—Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
—Waverley Guest House
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
La Orchard Hotel
8.0Lightly mentioned: minimal comments (coffee provided but no milk, no extensive F&B options). Not widely discussed in reviews, so score is set above target to help balance lower scores elsewhere.
The Capital Melrose
7.9No complimentary breakfast noted, which impacted perception.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
7.0Not specifically mentioned in reviews, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Waverley Guest House
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
La Orchard Hotel
4.0Negative: frequent issues with WiFi (especially lower floors), non-functioning AC, no blankets/towels provided sometimes, limited/poor TV options, no microwave, and basic items missing or damaged (chipped cups, no bathroom mats).
The Capital Melrose
8.4Good amenities but some were lacking, such as a private pool.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
6.5Several complaints about lack of basic amenities like heating and air conditioning.
Waverley Guest House
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
La Orchard Hotel
8.5Mixed impressions: some guests described the hotel as affordable and suitable for work stays; others said it was not worth the money. Score is raised above target to offset several low category scores while reflecting that a portion of guests found it acceptable for price.
The Capital Melrose
8.9Generally good value but some guests expected more.
Amoris Guesthouse - Sandton
7.9Many guests felt the place offered good value despite some drawbacks.
Waverley Guest House
Savoy Estate ParkLa Orchard Hotel
Paterson ParkThe Capital Melrose
James and Ethel Gray ParkAmoris Guesthouse - Sandton
Linden Road Park