
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
Scarborough, GB
0.15 km (0.10 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Scarborough, GB
0.15 km (0.10 mi) from original
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Scarborough, GB
0.84 km (0.52 mi) from original

Scarborough, GB
0.15 km (0.10 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Weston Hotel
9.4/10Highlander Hotel
7.7/10The Grand Scarborough
6.4/10The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
8/10Weston Hotel
9.3Rooms are well-appointed with fantastic views and described positively.
Highlander Hotel
7.3Comfortable and spacious rooms, but some mention of old fittings.
The Grand Scarborough
5.7Concerns about dated decor and comfort, with some rooms needing repair.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
7.5Rooms were generally described as clean and comfortable, but some concerns about smells were noted.
Weston Hotel
9.5The hotel is noted for being spotlessly clean across reviews.
Highlander Hotel
6.8Cleanliness of bathroom poor, hotel a bit tired.
The Grand Scarborough
5.2Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, including shabbiness and bathroom problems.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
7.1There were mentions of unpleasant smells in the room and some areas described as a little tired.
Weston Hotel
9.3The location was perfect and well-placed according to multiple reviews.
Highlander Hotel
8.3Great location with walking distance to the center and view of South Bay.
The Grand Scarborough
8.2Comments indicated the location was convenient and liked by guests.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
8.6The location is consistently praised as brilliant and convenient.
Weston Hotel
9.8Staff were described as excellent and accommodating throughout the stay.
Highlander Hotel
8.3Friendly and helpful staff throughout various reviews.
The Grand Scarborough
7.7Although the staff were hardworking and friendly, they were noted to be understaffed.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
8.6Staff were described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Weston Hotel
—Highlander Hotel
—The Grand Scarborough
—The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
—Weston Hotel
9.5Food received very positive remarks, being described as amazing.
Highlander Hotel
7.8Good breakfast and decent food at the bar.
The Grand Scarborough
5.2Food quality was generally reported as poor, with many complaints about choice and temperature.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
8.1Breakfast was generally well-received but mentioned that cereal choices could improve.
Weston Hotel
8.8Amenities like dining areas and bar were well presented and praised.
Highlander Hotel
7.8Facilities include a bar and food service; breakfast praised but shower issues noted.
The Grand Scarborough
6.7Facilities available but noted shortages in some amenities and furniture.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
7.6Facilities were appreciated, but noted could use some updating.
Weston Hotel
9.3Guests felt the experience provided good value, considering quality.
Highlander Hotel
7.8Good value for the price with several positive mentions.
The Grand Scarborough
6.2While some viewed the value as good given pricing, others felt let down for what they received.
The Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
8.5Value for money was highlighted positively in several reviews.
Weston Hotel
Prince of Wales GardensHighlander Hotel
Oliver SaronyThe Grand Scarborough
Anne BrontëThe Caledonian New Southlands Hotel
Granville Square