
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.5Rooms were well-kept, but a few reviews indicated some were jaded or drafty.
Cleanliness
8.8Guest comments consistently praised cleanliness throughout the reviews.
Value
8.7Guests found value satisfactory, though breakfast variety needs enhancement.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 3.3 km.
Elfordleigh Hotel: 1.1 km (0.65 mi)
Welbeck Manor and Golf: 4.3 km (2.7 mi)
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
9.4/10Elfordleigh Hotel
8.6/10ibis Plymouth
8.6/10Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.4/10Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
8.9Room quality generally well-finished, though some issues with size and cleanliness.
Elfordleigh Hotel
8.7Rooms were generally described as comfortable and well-appointed.
ibis Plymouth
8.5Rooms were well-kept, but a few reviews indicated some were jaded or drafty.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.4Rooms were noted as comfortable and spacious, with some issues raised intermittently.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
8.0Several issues with cleanliness noted, including black hairs in the bath.
Elfordleigh Hotel
7.7Some guests noted issues with room cleanliness, including stains on carpets.
ibis Plymouth
8.8Guest comments consistently praised cleanliness throughout the reviews.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
7.9General cleanliness was commented on positively, although there were issues with the dining room floor.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
10.0Beautiful country setting, adding to the overall charm of the hotel.
Elfordleigh Hotel
8.7Guests appreciated the beautiful and tranquil location.
ibis Plymouth
8.6Location was generally convenient, though some comments suggested it could be improved.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.4Described positively, particularly regarding its convenience.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
9.9Generally helpful staff, but inconsistent service noted.
Elfordleigh Hotel
9.2Many reviews highlighted the attentive and friendly service from staff.
ibis Plymouth
8.9Staff received high praise for being friendly and helpful.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.9Staff were consistently praised for being helpful and friendly.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
—Elfordleigh Hotel
—ibis Plymouth
—Welbeck Manor and Golf
—Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
10.0Food quality was high, although some dishes were criticized for portion size.
Elfordleigh Hotel
8.9Food quality received high praise, despite some service delays.
ibis Plymouth
8.5Breakfast options received mixed feedback, but food in general was praised.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.9Food quality received high praise for both variety and taste.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
9.5Great spa facilities, although some parts were out of service.
Elfordleigh Hotel
8.2Amenities like the swimming pool and spa were generally well-received.
ibis Plymouth
8.4Basic amenities were adequate, but suggested improvements in power sockets were mentioned.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
7.9Amenities were mostly appreciated, though there were some operational issues with heating.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
8.9A bit expensive for the services offered.
Elfordleigh Hotel
8.7Described as good value for money by guests, especially considering the ambiance.
ibis Plymouth
8.7Guests found value satisfactory, though breakfast variety needs enhancement.
Welbeck Manor and Golf
8.4Guests felt overall value was good, but some indicated it might not match expectations during issues.
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
Railway bridge supportsElfordleigh Hotel
Railway bridge supportsibis Plymouth
The Plymouth Blitz War MemorialWelbeck Manor and Golf
Sparkwell Village Sign