Our pick
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
Medicine Hat, CA
★ 4-star9.6/10580 reviews
0.71 km (0.44 mi) from original
English
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.4Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable in multiple reviews.
Location
10.0Well located with shopping options nearby, positively mentioned in the reviews.
Service
10.0Consistently praised for friendly and helpful staff across multiple reviews.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
Medicine Hat, CA
★ 4-star7/101,259 reviews
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
Medicine Hat, CA
★ 4-star8.8/10482 reviews
0.31 km (0.19 mi) from original
Our pick
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
Medicine Hat, CA
★ 4-star9.6/10580 reviews
0.71 km (0.44 mi) from original
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
Medicine Hat, CA
★ 4-star8.4/101,206 reviews
0.21 km (0.13 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat9.4
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham6.5
Cleanliness
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG9.3
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham6.6
Location
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat10.0
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham8.6
Service
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat10.0
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham8.1
Food & Breakfast
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat10.0
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham6.6
Amenities & Facilities
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat9.0
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham6.1
Value
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat9.9
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham6.5
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat amenity advantages
SaunaConcierge service
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
7/10Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
8.8/10Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
9.6/10Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
8.4/10Rooms
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
6.5Rooms were described as outdated and basic, with specific mentions of issues like a broken shower.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
8.2Some issues were mentioned regarding room features, like the noisy AC.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
9.4Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable in multiple reviews.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
8.2Comfortable beds noted, but issues with room size and temperature control.
Cleanliness
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
6.6Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, such as outdated rooms and bed bugs.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
9.3Guests noted clean rooms and overall good hygiene.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
8.5Several reviews indicated cleanliness issues, especially related to the jacuzzi suite.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
7.7Issues mentioned regarding pet hair and cleaning services.
Location
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
8.6Location was frequently praised for convenience and accessibility.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
9.3Location was convenient for travelers passing through.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
10.0Well located with shopping options nearby, positively mentioned in the reviews.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
8.8Great location mentioned frequently by guests.
Service
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
8.1Front desk staff were described positively, but some noted rudeness from housekeeping.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
9.2Service was highlighted positively, especially staff responsiveness.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
10.0Consistently praised for friendly and helpful staff across multiple reviews.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
9.2Great staff and customer service noted, despite some isolated incidents.
Sleep & Noise
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
—Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
—Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
—Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
—Food & Breakfast
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
6.6Breakfast was noted as not very good, impacting the overall dining experience.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
8.3Breakfast received good comments but had some shortcomings.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
10.0Breakfast was highly praised, although some specific items were criticized.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
7.7Breakfast quality was good, but limited selection noted.
Amenities & Facilities
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
6.1Many complaints regarding the pool, hot tub not working, and overall amenities were lacking.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
8.8Amenities lacked certain essentials but were generally satisfactory.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
9.0Amenities like the pool and breakfast received positive comments, but some issues were noted.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
8.2Good amenities but lacking in minor facilities like breakfast selection.
Value
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
6.5High prices were mentioned, especially considering the quality of the hotel.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
8.7On the expensive side, but satisfactory for the quality provided.
Best Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
9.9Generally considered a good value based on the positive experiences shared.
Comfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
8.7Fair assessment of value for the price paid.
Landmarks
Medicine Hat Lodge, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
Ross Haven Finger ParkHoliday Inn Express & Suites Medicine Hat by IHG
Thompson ParkBest Western Premier Executive Residency Medicine Hat
Thompson ParkComfort Inn & Suites Medicine Hat Shopping Centre
Ross Haven Finger Park