
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.3Rooms were spacious and comfortable but noted for age and cleanliness issues.
Cleanliness
8.3Multiple mentions of rooms being clean, but also mentions of blood stains and bed bugs.
Service
9.0Staff was friendly, but inconsistencies in service quality noted.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Duncan, CA
4.6 km (2.8 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 2.9 km.
Duncan Motel: 1.7 km (1.1 mi)
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn: 4.6 km (2.8 mi)
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
6.3/10Thunderbird Motor Inn
8.8/10Duncan Motel
7.4/10Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
8/10Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
6.3Rooms were described as clean but in need of maintenance and modernization, with issues like tiny size and noise.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
8.3Rooms were spacious and comfortable but noted for age and cleanliness issues.
Duncan Motel
6.5Rooms are clean but generally considered small and in need of updates.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
7.7Rooms were comfortable but some lacked separation and might need improvement.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
5.3Several comments indicated issues with cleanliness and maintenance, such as a dusty smell and termite damage.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
8.3Multiple mentions of rooms being clean, but also mentions of blood stains and bed bugs.
Duncan Motel
8.0Clean and tidy but some rooms showing signs of age.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
8.1Many reviews praised the cleanliness of the property, noting rooms were clean and well-maintained.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
5.3Multiple reviews cited a bad location, mentioning outside noise and unsavory surroundings.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
7.3The area is described as dangerous with homelessness and drug issues.
Duncan Motel
7.5Conveniently located but in a questionable neighborhood.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
8.3Convenient access to transportation and nearby dining options was frequently noted.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
7.3Staff were noted as friendly and helpful, but inconsistencies in professionalism were mentioned.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
9.0Staff was friendly, but inconsistencies in service quality noted.
Duncan Motel
8.5Friendly and accommodating staff throughout all interactions.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
8.7Generally good service as mentioned, with staff being described as kind and helpful.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
—Thunderbird Motor Inn
—Duncan Motel
—Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
—Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
6.8Breakfast was described as basic but adequate, with room for improvement noted.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
9.3No specific feedback, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Duncan Motel
7.0Offers basic options and nearby fast food; no dining facility on site.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
8.3Breakfast received positive remarks, though some found options a bit limited.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
6.8General comments about basics. Some amenities were missing or not functional, like the hot tub and stable chairs.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
8.8Basic amenities were met, but specific mentions of shortcomings were rare.
Duncan Motel
6.0Limited amenities, lacking basics like an iron or tea.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
7.8Basic amenities were satisfactory but some facilities like the pool needed cleaning.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
5.3Many reviews felt the pricing did not match the quality offered, indicating it's a bit overpriced.
Thunderbird Motor Inn
9.8Good price for the quality of rooms, despite several issues.
Duncan Motel
8.0Good price for the basic services offered.
Best Western Cowichan Valley Inn
7.3Some guests felt the rates were somewhat high for the offerings, but overall it was decent.
Super 8 by Wyndham Duncan
Chaster Road TrailThunderbird Motor Inn
Spirit PoleDuncan Motel
Spirit PoleBest Western Cowichan Valley Inn
Averill Creek Park