
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.7Rooms were comfortable, but some minor issues noted, like bed frame sticking out.
Cleanliness
9.2Guests consistently noted the hotel as very clean and tidy.
Location
9.2Conveniently located within a short walk to the city center.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
8.6/10Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
8.9/10The Milner York
8.2/10The Apple House
9.1/10Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
8.7Rooms were often described as lovely, spacious, and well-decorated.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
8.3Mixed reviews; some rooms were described as comfortable while others had issues with mattress quality.
The Milner York
7.9Comments indicate some rooms are small and have issues with lighting and air conditioning.
The Apple House
8.7Rooms were comfortable, but some minor issues noted, like bed frame sticking out.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
8.2Some reviewers mentioned cleanliness positively, but lack of towel change and room odors affected the sentiment.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
8.4Several reviews mentioned clean rooms; however, one reviewer noted issues with beds and cleanliness of sheets.
The Milner York
7.9Some reviews mention cleanliness, but also note issues like tired paint and cracked marks.
The Apple House
9.2Guests consistently noted the hotel as very clean and tidy.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
9.3The hotel is conveniently located near the old town, making it easy to explore.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
9.4Positive feedback regarding the convenience of location to city center.
The Milner York
9.4The hotel's location was frequently praised for being ideal, especially for New Year celebrations.
The Apple House
9.2Conveniently located within a short walk to the city center.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
9.2Staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful, with great service at breakfast.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
9.3Consistently praised across multiple reviews for being friendly and helpful.
The Milner York
9.4Guests highlighted the outstanding and accommodating service from the staff.
The Apple House
9.7Staff were described as friendly, helpful, and engaging.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
—Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
—The Milner York
—The Apple House
—Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
7.7Food service quality was often criticized with poor breakfast and bar options.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
9.4Breakfast and dining options received high praise in several reviews.
The Milner York
6.9Breakfast options received poor reviews, especially concerning quality and variety.
The Apple House
8.7Breakfast received mixed reviews, but overall was enjoyed by most guests.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
8.2Limited amenities were mentioned, particularly regarding the restaurant and parking.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
8.8Good amenities mentioned, such as a well-stocked bar and breakfast options.
The Milner York
7.4Facilities like the spa and pool were noted as unavailable, with breakfast options lacking.
The Apple House
8.7Amenities were standard for a B&B, with sufficient supplies provided.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
8.7Reviewers found the value for the location and accommodations to be fair despite some additional costs.
Wheatlands Lodge Hotel
8.3Good value mentioned relative to quality, with some concerns about specific amenities.
The Milner York
7.9Mixed feelings about prices versus offered services and quality (e.g., breakfast quality).
The Apple House
9.2Guests felt the overall offering provided good value for the price.
Elmbank York, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
George Butterworth MCWheatlands Lodge Hotel
St Stephen's OrphanageThe Milner York
Cholera Burial GroundThe Apple House
George Butterworth MC