Malmaison Edinburgh City vs Similar Hotels

Rooms are described as magnificent, spacious, and comfy.

The room was spacious, clean, and airy, showcasing good quality.

Rooms described as beautiful and delightful, but some issues reported.

Generally comfortable but issues like heating and maintenance reported.

Staff was super helpful, everything cleaned very well.

The room was amazing and clean, indicating excellent cleanliness.

Rooms are in bad condition and not clean, with stains reported.

Multiple reviews mentioned cleanliness issues and a lack of room maintenance.

Perfect location for accessing all parts of Edinburgh on foot.

Excellent location highlighted in several reviews.

Location is highlighted as very nice and well-placed near attractions.

Many enjoyed the location, though some noted construction affecting accessibility.

The staff was consistently praised for their attentiveness and help throughout multiple reviews.

Staff very friendly and helpful, with excellent service mentioned multiple times.

Varied service experiences, with some positive mentions but significant complaints.

Overall positive feedback on service, with specific praises for staff being helpful.

Fantastic food experiences highlighted in several reviews.

Breakfast had a good quality but lacked variety, impacting the score.

Good food experience but some minor complaints about specific items.

Food quality received positive remarks, particularly regarding bar food.

Overall good amenities were mentioned, with the onsite restaurant and bar receiving compliments.

Amenities were generally mentioned positively; however, some breakfast issues noted.

Amenities mentioned were good, but minor issues reported.

Limited amenities reported, such as broken heating and lack of expected luxury.

General feedback suggests good value, though not explicitly detailed in the text.

Overall, guests felt it was worth the price, despite some comments on pricing.

Felt hotel is not delivering on small things for the price paid.

Some guests felt that the experience did not match what they paid for, especially with the building work.