
The Knickerbocker Hotel
New York, US
0.35 km (0.21 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

New York, US
0.35 km (0.21 mi) from original
Rooms
9.3Spacious and comfortable rooms, though some were noted to lack natural light.
Cleanliness
8.3Notable mentions of cleanliness, but some maintenance issues reported.
Service
9.8Exceptional service and hospitality from staff, particularly during special occasions.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


New York, US
0.35 km (0.21 mi) from original

New York, US
0.25 km (0.16 mi) from original

New York, US
0.56 km (0.35 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.2/10The Knickerbocker Hotel
9/10Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
7.5/10Hotel Edison Times Square
7.9/10The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Rooms are noted as small but very comfortable, with some statements indicating that furniture should be better adapted.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.3Spacious and comfortable rooms, though some were noted to lack natural light.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
6.3Room quality varied, with concerns about cleanliness and amenities needing updates.
Hotel Edison Times Square
7.7Rooms are decent size but can be hot and with issues such as noisy AC.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Some reviews highlighted the presence of a roach in the room, suggesting room cleanliness could be improved.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.3Notable mentions of cleanliness, but some maintenance issues reported.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
5.9Cleanliness was a recurring issue mentioned in multiple reviews, indicating a need for significant improvement.
Hotel Edison Times Square
7.7Rooms are clean and suitable for a short stay.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
10.0Frequent mentions of the perfect midtown location near major attractions.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.3Great location in the center of Times Square, easy access to transportation.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
9.4Many reviews praised the location, highlighting its convenience and proximity to attractions.
Hotel Edison Times Square
8.7Great central location near all sights and transportation.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
10.0Consistently praised across multiple reviews for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.8Exceptional service and hospitality from staff, particularly during special occasions.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
8.4Staff received positive feedback for being professional and helpful, contributing to a good service experience.
Hotel Edison Times Square
8.0Staff was friendly and helpful, but there were issues with post-stay customer service.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
—The Knickerbocker Hotel
—Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
—Hotel Edison Times Square
—The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.0Generally good breakfast mentioned, though can be crowded at peak times.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.8Positive comments about restaurant food and service.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
7.9Food and beverage options were not discussed extensively, treated as standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Edison Times Square
7.2Breakfast format not convenient; limited variety and items running out.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Good amenities noted, but some guests found the breakfast area too busy at times.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.8Good amenities, though some guests expressed a desire for improvements.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
6.9Mixed sentiment regarding amenities; some were functional while others were reported as out of order.
Hotel Edison Times Square
8.1Decent amenities like wine hour and walking tours, but breakfast options need improvement.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.5Overall good value with breakfast included and helpful staff.
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.3Hotel is not cheap but offers good value for the quality of stay.
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
7.3Value perception was generally fair but affected by cleanliness and maintenance issues.
Hotel Edison Times Square
7.7Questionable relation between price and services given the size and quality of the rooms.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
Marsh & McLennan Public SpaceThe Knickerbocker Hotel
Times Square BallMillennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
Times SquareHotel Edison Times Square
Francis P. Duffy