Our pick
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
Saint Andrews, CA
★ 3-star9/10226 reviews
0.81 km (0.50 mi) from original
English
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.7Mixed sentiment; some rooms had issues but overall comfort was highlighted.
Location
9.6Conveniently located near attractions, positively mentioned in several reviews.
Service
10.0Hosts are described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
Saint Andrews, CA
★ 5-star8.7/101,035 reviews
St Andrews Inn & Suites
Saint Andrews, CA
★ 3-star8.4/10750 reviews
0.58 km (0.36 mi) from original
Our pick
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
Saint Andrews, CA
★ 3-star9/10226 reviews
0.81 km (0.50 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection8.8
Kennedy House7.6
Cleanliness
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection8.3
Kennedy House7.7
Service
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe10.0
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection8.8
Food & Breakfast
Kennedy House8.2
St Andrews Inn & Suites6.9
Amenities & Facilities
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection8.8
Kennedy House8.2
Value
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe9.7
Kennedy House8.1
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection amenity advantages
Fitness centerSwimming poolRoom serviceBusiness centerSpa/wellness center
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.7/10St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4/10Kennedy House
8.3/10The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9/10Rooms
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.8Overall room quality was good, but some complaints about bed size.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
7.9Rooms reported as dated and in need of updates.
Kennedy House
7.6Several mentions of dated rooms and inconsistent amenities.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.7Mixed sentiment; some rooms had issues but overall comfort was highlighted.
Cleanliness
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.3Room cleanliness was acceptable, but some dissatisfaction with check-in delays and room readiness.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
7.9The cleanliness was a concern with reports of dirty rooms and mold.
Kennedy House
7.7Some comments indicate issues with old, stained carpets and other cleanliness concerns.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
7.7Multiple mentions of dirty sheets and overall cleanliness issues.
Location
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
9.3Great location with beautiful views and proximity to local attractions.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
9.4Consistently praised for a beautiful and convenient location.
Kennedy House
9.2Reviews frequently highlight the perfect central location.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9.6Conveniently located near attractions, positively mentioned in several reviews.
Service
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.8Staff were friendly and helpful in most instances, though check-in experience was notably poor.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
9.4Staff were frequently mentioned as friendly and helpful.
Kennedy House
9.1Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
10.0Hosts are described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.
Sleep & Noise
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
—St Andrews Inn & Suites
—Kennedy House
—The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
—Food & Breakfast
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
7.8Food quality was inconsistent, with some meals described as terrible.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
6.9Limited breakfast selection and negative comments on free donuts.
Kennedy House
8.2Restaurant meals received mixed feedback but generally considered decent.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.1Limited options for food and drinks were mentioned by guests.
Amenities & Facilities
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.8Amenities like the pool and dining options available but with some mixed reviews about food quality.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4Amenities like the pool received mixed reviews but overall acceptable.
Kennedy House
8.2Amenities like the bar and entertainment were positively noted, but limited options such as no breakfast impacted the score.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
8.6Some amenities were lacking, such as limited breakfast offerings and room appliances.
Value
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
8.8Overall good value despite some issues, but additional charges (e.g., activity fee) were unexpected.
St Andrews Inn & Suites
8.4Some reviews felt the price was high given the condition of the rooms.
Kennedy House
8.1Most reviews express that the hotel provides good value for the price.
The Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
9.7Overall guests felt it provided good value for the price.
Landmarks
The Algonquin Resort St. Andrews by-the-Sea, Autograph Collection
Centennial ParkSt Andrews Inn & Suites
Drug Store MuralKennedy House
Canadian War MemorialThe Montague Rose Inn & Cafe
Drug Store Mural