Macdonald Tickled Trout Hotel vs Similar Hotels

Outdated everything and poor room upkeep.

Most rooms were reported as comfortable, though a few had specific issues.

The bed was itchy and uncomfortable with a bulge in the center.

Some rooms were spacious but had issues like stains and noise.

Horrible smell and outdated conditions.

Generally clean rooms mentioned but noted issues with drains and window frames.

The jug of water in the gym had mould growing, and the shower took a long time to warm up.

Rooms were dirty, stained carpets, and bad smells.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Good location with some issues mentioned regarding noise from nearby facilities.

Location not explicitly mentioned but implied positive given amenities.

Great location near M6 and convenient for travel.

Terrible service and careless management.

Service was consistently praised across multiple reviews.

Lovely staff and very helpful & friendly service noted in multiple reviews.

Staff were friendly, helpful, and provided good service.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Food quality was frequently highlighted as excellent.

Menu options were limited with many items not available.

Food was of good quality, though limited menu.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities were positively received, although limited direct mentions.

Gym was satisfactory but had issues with cleanliness and water availability.

Basic amenities present but some missing like hair dryer and tea spoons.

Considered a money grabber by some guests.

Some reviews mentioned feeling prices were a bit high.

Price considered good according to a recent reviewer.

Good value for a budget hotel, but not exceptional.