Our pick
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
Saint Louis, US
★ 4-star9.4/10616 reviews
0.72 km (0.45 mi) from original
English
The Westin St. Louis vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
8.8Some guests felt the cleanliness did not meet expectations, particularly in the bathroom.
Location
10.0Centrally located and convenient for various attractions.
Service
9.8Staff were reported as pleasant and helpful, with specific praise for attentiveness.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
Saint Louis, US
★ 4-star7.6/101,355 reviews
0.39 km (0.24 mi) from original
Our pick
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
Saint Louis, US
★ 4-star9.4/10616 reviews
0.72 km (0.45 mi) from original
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
Saint Louis, US
★ 4-star9/10720 reviews
0.73 km (0.46 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Westin St. Louis9.7
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark6.5
Cleanliness
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch8.8
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark5.5
Location
The Westin St. Louis10.0
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark9.1
Service
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel9.9
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark9.0
Food & Breakfast
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch9.8
The Westin St. Louis6.2
Amenities & Facilities
The Westin St. Louis9.7
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark7.5
Value
The Westin St. Louis9.7
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark7.5
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark amenity advantages
Swimming poolSaunaSun loungers or beach chairsFitness/spa locker rooms
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel amenity advantages
Free WiFi
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Westin St. Louis
8.8/10Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
7.6/10Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
9.4/10Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
9/10Rooms
The Westin St. Louis
9.7The room was nice after they gave us the correct one.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
6.5Issues with heating and general room condition were noted, despite a clean sheet.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
8.8Rooms were spacious but showed signs of aging; upgrades needed.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
7.9Room quality was noted as problematic in some reviews, with issues like uncomfortable beds.
Cleanliness
The Westin St. Louis
6.2The cleanliness of my room was unacceptable. The toilet was visibly dirty, and both the shower and sink drains were clogged and unable to drain properly.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
5.5Multiple remarks about unclean conditions, such as pubic hair in shower and dirty windows.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
8.8Some guests felt the cleanliness did not meet expectations, particularly in the bathroom.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
8.5Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness and maintenance.
Location
The Westin St. Louis
10.0The hotel was in a perfect location, highly appreciated by guests.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
9.1Positively mentioned for convenience related to events and conferences.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
10.0Centrally located and convenient for various attractions.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
10.0Positive remarks regarding the hotel's location and accessibility to attractions.
Service
The Westin St. Louis
9.7Some staff showed genuine hospitality, while others were unhelpful, creating a mixed impression of service.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
9.0Caren received specific praise for her professional and helpful demeanor.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
9.8Staff were reported as pleasant and helpful, with specific praise for attentiveness.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
9.9Many guests highlighted the helpfulness and kindness of the staff.
Sleep & Noise
The Westin St. Louis
—Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
—Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
—Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
The Westin St. Louis
6.2Breakfast was gross and there were issues with the order.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
7.5Breakfast was appreciated, but dinner options were criticized.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
9.8No specific mentions, but typically meets expectations for this hotel tier.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
9.5Food quality and dining experience were positively recognized, though accessibility issues noted.
Amenities & Facilities
The Westin St. Louis
9.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
7.5Lack of expected amenities like the executive lounge impacted satisfaction.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
9.3Standard amenities were provided, but some issues reported with functionality.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
8.9General sentiment indicated some good amenities, but issues were mentioned.
Value
The Westin St. Louis
9.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
7.5High price point with several mentioned issues led to disappointment.
Hilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
8.8Parking and other fees were higher than expected, affecting perceived value.
Magnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
7.9Several comments indicated concerns about value considering the price point.
Landmarks
The Westin St. Louis
Out of the ParkHilton St. Louis at the Ballpark
Fort San CarlosHilton Pennywell St Louis at the Arch
Corinthian CapitalMagnolia Hotel St. Louis, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
Mercantile Building