The Commodore Hotel vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were adequate but had some issues, such as noise and booking errors.

Comfy beds and large bathroom, but some noise issues reported.

Some apartments noted as being run down with minor issues.

Rooms described as comfy and well-equipped with cosy beds, but some issues reported (cold/clammy in season, design dislikes like twin beds/headboards, occasional TV faults and power outage) lowering the score.

The hotel was clean, but there were mentions of noise from building work.

The hotel and room were spotless.

Cleaning staff visited a few times, towels were not always changed.

Generally reported as clean (rooms cleaned daily, facilities described as clean and well maintained) but occasional housekeeping inconsistencies (missing/irregular towel changes) and comments about cold/clammy rooms reduce the score.

Exceptional vicinity to the V&A waterfront, praised across reviews.

Location was ideal for travel and convenience.

Excellent location, close to attractions like the V&A Waterfront.

Repeatedly highlighted as excellent and central (near V&A Waterfront, easy to explore the city), though a few guests noted noise issues depending on room placement.

Staff were generally helpful and friendly, with some exceptions.

Some issues with staff responsiveness, but generally friendly and helpful.

Overall service was good, with reliable staff available to assist.

Consistently praised across many reviews (amazing, friendly, accommodating staff; helpful with check-in, planning and connecting rooms), giving service a very strong positive rating.

Breakfast and other meals received mixed reviews; some praised but limited options.

Breakfast options were limited and some service issues experienced.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Breakfast is praised in many reviews (good selection, enjoyable), yet some guests reported disappointing pastries (stale/old), limited choices at times, and a slightly chaotic breakfast at peak periods.

Pool was under construction, and Wi-Fi issues were mentioned.

Good, though some suggestions for improvements, like more water and modern coffee machines.

Well equipped apartments with modern furnishings, though some amenities appeared dated.

Mixed feedback: helpful bar/cafe and well-equipped rooms, but several mentions that the pool is very small (more like a tub) and some inconsistent replenishment of in-room supplies; minor reliability issues with in-room coffee machine.

Perceived as expensive for the quality received, especially regarding breakfast.

Generally considered good for the price and location.

Good value for the location and size of the apartment.

Many find location and service justify the price, but a few comments mention the hotel is slightly overpriced or basic for the rate, so value is positive but not top-tier.