Our pick
English
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Location
9.2Convenient location for various needs, often mentioned positively.
Value
9.2Good value for the price paid, as noted by several guests.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
Rotherham, GB
★ 2-star7.7/101,721 reviews
1.4 km (0.89 mi) from original
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
Rotherham, GB
★ 4-star7.5/10952 reviews
2.6 km (1.6 mi) from original
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms7.7
Cleanliness7.2
Service9.7
Food & Breakfast9.2
Amenities & Facilities8.2
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Cleanliness7.1
Food & Breakfast8.4
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Cleanliness6.6
Key differences
Rooms
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG7.7
The Welcome Inn6.7
Cleanliness
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG7.2
The Welcome Inn5.7
Location
The Welcome Inn9.2
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG8.3
Service
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG9.7
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant8.1
Food & Breakfast
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG9.2
The Welcome Inn5.7
Amenities & Facilities
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG8.2
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns7.3
Value
The Welcome Inn9.2
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns7.8
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG amenity advantages
Swimming poolSaunaConference spaceBreakfast available (surcharge)Accessible shuttle
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant amenity advantages
Pets allowedElectric vehicle charging station
The Welcome Inn amenity advantages
Lift / ElevatorWheelchair accessible
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.9 km.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns: 1.4 km (0.89 mi)
The Welcome Inn: 4.4 km (2.7 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.4/10Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
7.7/10The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
7.5/10The Welcome Inn
7.7/10Rooms
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
7.7Room conditions included issues like cracked sink and hanging curtains; refurbishment is needed.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
6.8Reviews highlighted issues with room maintenance and heating.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
7.1Mixed sentiments; some rooms very modern, but issues like cold temperatures and inadequate shower facilities noted.
The Welcome Inn
6.7Some rooms were comfortable, but many had issues with beds and cleanliness.
Cleanliness
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
7.2The room had a mouldy smell, stained lampshades, and the bathrooms showed signs of mold and neglect.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
7.1Several reviews mentioned dated rooms and some cleanliness issues.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
6.6Consistently mentioned issues with cleanliness, including filthy rooms.
The Welcome Inn
5.7Many reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, including dirty sheets and unpleasant odors.
Location
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.3Convenient for events at the Don Valley arena and close to Meadowhall Interchange.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
8.4Multiple reviews praised the location as convenient and enjoyable.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
8.7Multiple reviews highlighted the great location.
The Welcome Inn
9.2Convenient location for various needs, often mentioned positively.
Service
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
9.7Staff were warm, welcoming, and responsive to guest needs, providing excellent service throughout the stay.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
8.3Overall, the staff were reported as friendly and helpful.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
8.1Friendly and welcoming staff, though some service issues noted.
The Welcome Inn
9.2Staff were frequently noted as friendly and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
—Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
—The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
—The Welcome Inn
—Food & Breakfast
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
9.2Variety of food options and good breakfast; however, drinks were considered expensive.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
8.4Positive comments about breakfast and overall food quality.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
6.1Negative feedback regarding breakfast quality.
The Welcome Inn
5.7Limited food options noted, with suggestions for improvement.
Amenities & Facilities
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.2The hotel offers a range of amenities including pools and gyms, but some were underutilized.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
7.3Some rooms lacked necessary bathroom supplies; otherwise satisfactory.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
7.6Some amenities were satisfactory but lacked certain essentials.
The Welcome Inn
7.7Basic amenities provided, though some guests expected more.
Value
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.2Overall decent value, but some guests felt the room quality did not justify the price.
Brentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
7.8Guests found the price reasonable for the services offered.
The George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
8.1Good value mentioned in several reviews, especially for location.
The Welcome Inn
9.2Good value for the price paid, as noted by several guests.
Landmarks
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
Blue Man's BowerBrentwood Inn by Greene King Inns
War MemorialThe George Wright Boutique Hotel, Bar & Restaurant
Compass Pebble MosaicThe Welcome Inn
Kimberworth Castle