Phi Phi Holiday Resort, Leam Tong Beach vs Similar Hotels

Some rooms were described as dated and in need of renovation.

Mixed reviews on room quality; some rooms were unpleasant while others were acceptable.

Rooms described as spacious and nice but several guests mentioned hard beds/pillows, some dated furnishings and one report of sewer smell in a room.

Rooms and villas frequently described positively (huge, spotless two-bedroom villa with great views); some comments about inability to open windows and AC reliance.

The rooms had old bathrooms and there were concerns about the cleanliness due to insects.

Some areas were not adequately cleaned, with mentions of dirty mattresses and surfaces.

Generally reported as very clean (rooms described as 'sehr sauber'), but occasional negative note about sewer/odour in one room.

Generally reported as very clean (spotless upgraded villa cited), though some areas (pool, older facilities) were noted as not well maintained.

Fantastic location for sunrises and sunsets, providing a peaceful escape from crowded areas.

Described as beautiful, providing great access to the beach and surrounding islands.

Highly praised for beautiful, tropical setting with sunrise and sunset views and quiet beachfront, but noted as isolated and requiring longboat transfers at night.

Highly regarded beachfront/island setting and resort surroundings; access depends on boat transfers and can be affected by tides (mentioned as a minor drawback).

The staff were very helpful and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience.

Staff was consistently described as welcoming and helpful, with particular praise for individuals.

Very positive: staff repeatedly described as friendly, attentive and 'aux petits soins'; chef noted for attentive breakfast service.

Consistently praised across reviews: friendly, accommodating staff, excellent welcome, helpful with boat/shore assistance and special requests (upgrades, engagement surprise).

Breakfast was a great buffet, but some reviews mentioned limited options.

Breakfast and some meals received positive feedback, while others were less favored.

Strongly positive: breakfast repeatedly praised as fabulous with great variety; specific praise for an 'incredible' Thai curry.

Breakfast repeatedly praised as excellent, several restaurants and dishes praised; some negative notes about specific dinner at Api and limited breakfast options/absence of some items.

The resort had good amenities, including various restaurants on the beach.

Amenities were generally nice, although some guests noted the pool and fitness facilities needed renovation.

Good amenities: nice pool, restaurants along the beach and well-kept grounds; downsides include aging sunbeds and lack of beach entertainment.

Good spa, gym and Marine Center highlighted, but pool(s) require maintenance (missing/broken tiles, cleanliness issues) which lowers the score.

Prices for some services like massages were noted as high compared to city rates.

Prices are higher relative to other regions in Thailand, but generally justified for the island.

Mixed: restful, picturesque stay but extra costs and inconvenience for transfers (expensive night boat returns) and limited beach facilities reduce perceived value.

Mixed signals: many loved the stay, but at least one guest felt it was not full 5-star value; additional on-site costs (buying water/milk) impacted perceived value.