The Sagamore Hotel South Beach vs Similar Hotels

Some guests found rooms comfortable, but others described issues with old facilities.

Rooms described as modern, fresh and spacious; some issues noted (windows that couldn't be opened, TV flicker) but overall positive.

The room size was decent but had a small bathroom and issues with cleanliness.

Some noise issues were reported, particularly regarding air conditioning and elevators.

Reviews mention clean and well-maintained property, but some guests reported issues.

Generally praised for high hygiene and very clean rooms, but an isolated report of a strong bathroom odor lowered the score slightly.

The room was reported to be dirty with mold, trash left in the room, and a musty smell.

Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness and maintenance, affecting the overall perception.

Multiple reviews praise the perfect location with direct access to the beach and boardwalk.

Consistently highlighted as excellent and well located (South Beach), frequently cited as a major positive.

The hotel is perfectly positioned next to the beach and close to many restaurants and cafes.

The location received high praise for its proximity to the beach and local attractions.

Outstanding service highlighted in multiple reviews, particularly from pool and front desk staff.

Multiple reports of warm, helpful and hospitable staff (doorman retrieved luggage, many compliments), though there are isolated incidents of inattentive or disrespectful staff and occasional privacy lapses.

Overall service was described positively, with mentions of friendly and helpful staff.

Reviews consistently praised the staff for being friendly and accommodating.

Excellent food options cited, particularly at the pool and beach.

Mixed to negative comments around breakfast: some guests noted breakfast not included for all, and one review explicitly called the breakfast poor.

Food was reported to be very good, though free coffee quality was criticized.

Food was generally viewed positively, though some found it expensive for the quality offered.

Amenities generally mentioned as a positive, but some complaints about costs.

Strong pool and beach-side amenities praised, but wifi instability, extra-fee wifi tiers, and complaints about parking/extra charges reduce the score.

Some activities available but concerns about the poolside bar closing early and additional fees for beach chairs.

Amenities such as the pool and gym were well-received, with some room for improvement.

Mixed reviews, with some stating high costs for certain services, though overall experience noted positively.

Several guests complained about extra charges (expensive valet/parking, paying for extra guests' breakfast, paid wifi tiers) leading to a below-target value perception.

The hotel was considered overpriced for the quality and cleanliness experienced.

Comments on prices being high and concerns over additional fees generated negative sentiment.