Our pick
Lancaster Arts Hotel
Lancaster, US
★ 3-star9/101,102 reviews
2.7 km (1.7 mi) from original
English
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.9Rooms generally spacious and comfortable, some minor complaints.
Cleanliness
9.0Rooms were clean and appointed beautifully.
Location
9.5Great location near downtown and within walking distance to many businesses.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
Lancaster, US
★ 3-star7.9/101,122 reviews
3.1 km (1.9 mi) from original
Our pick
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
Lancaster, US
★ 3-star8.4/10621 reviews
3.5 km (2.2 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Lancaster Arts Hotel8.9
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG6.4
Cleanliness
Lancaster Arts Hotel9.0
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG5.4
Location
Lancaster Arts Hotel9.5
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG8.4
Service
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection9.9
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square9.3
Food & Breakfast
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG9.4
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square8.3
Amenities & Facilities
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection9.4
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square7.8
Value
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection9.4
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG6.9
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection amenity advantages
SaunaHot tub/JacuzziConcierge service
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG amenity advantages
Pets allowed
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerBreakfast in the room
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.84 km.
Lancaster Arts Hotel: 2.7 km (1.7 mi)
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square: 3.5 km (2.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
9.2/10Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
7.9/10Lancaster Arts Hotel
9/10Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
8.4/10Rooms
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
8.4Rooms praised for beauty but some found beds uncomfortable.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
6.4Repeated complaints about bugs suggest significant room quality issues.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
8.9Rooms generally spacious and comfortable, some minor complaints.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
8.3Generally good, but some issues with pillows in specific rooms.
Cleanliness
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
8.4Generally clean, but some reviews mentioned dirty towels and issues with bathroom doors.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
5.4Multiple reviews indicated bugs in the bathroom, which severely impacted cleanliness.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
9.0Rooms were clean and appointed beautifully.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
7.8Mixed feedback, with several mentions of cleanliness issues, especially regarding the pool.
Location
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
9.4Well-located for family activities with easy access to amenities.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
8.4Location is convenient but not appreciated by some guests who disliked the city environment.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
9.5Great location near downtown and within walking distance to many businesses.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
9.3Great location with good nearby amenities and atmosphere.
Service
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
9.9Staff received high praise, particularly for their assistance and compassion.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
9.4Some staff were responsive, but overall service lacked compassion during issues.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
9.4Friendly staff and great service mentioned multiple times.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
9.3Friendly and helpful staff mentioned in multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
—Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
—Lancaster Arts Hotel
—Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
—Food & Breakfast
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
8.9Food options were available, but breakfast not included in stay.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
9.4Guests enjoyed the breakfast, particularly the friendly service and the kids eat free policy.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
8.5Breakfast could be upgraded, but restaurant experience was positive.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
8.3Good food but missed complimentary breakfast.
Amenities & Facilities
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
9.4Great amenities including pools and holiday decorations.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
8.9Basic amenities were present, but limited options like the absence of microwaves were noted.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
8.4Good amenities mentioned, but the breakfast and some facilities need improvement.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
7.8Good amenities but limited availability, especially towels at the pool.
Value
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
9.4Affordable pricing for a quality experience.
Holiday Inn Lancaster by IHG
6.9Guests expressed dissatisfaction with pricing relative to the quality received.
Lancaster Arts Hotel
8.9Good value but with some aspects that were disappointing considering the price.
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square
7.7Concerns regarding extra charges for parking and wifi.
Landmarks
Eden Resort and Suites, BW Premier Collection
Skyline ParkHoliday Inn Lancaster by IHG
Binns ParkLancaster Arts Hotel
Mayor Janice C Stork Corridor ParkLancaster Marriott at Penn Square
Soldiers and Sailors Monument