
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Rooms were comfortable, well-equipped, and modern.
Cleanliness
8.8Overall clean accommodation, but noted a slight smell and occasional housekeeping issues.
Value
8.8Good price for the quality provided, but some complaints about extra charges.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Auckland, NZ
2.9 km (1.8 mi) from original

Auckland, NZ
4.5 km (2.8 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.6 km.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre: 2.9 km (1.8 mi)
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel: 4.5 km (2.8 mi)
Mount Richmond Hotel
7.4/10Quest Highbrook
8.9/10Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
8.5/10Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
8.2/10Mount Richmond Hotel
7.2Mixed comments about the room comfort but generally acceptable.
Quest Highbrook
9.3Rooms were comfortable, well-equipped, and modern.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
8.9Rooms were spacious and comfortable; some parts were renovated.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
9.6Rooms described as large and well-furnished.
Mount Richmond Hotel
6.2Several comments mention cleanliness issues, including unclean rooms and lost property.
Quest Highbrook
8.8Overall clean accommodation, but noted a slight smell and occasional housekeeping issues.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
7.0Bathroom was dirty and not cleaned properly; some areas needed attention.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
7.1Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness and maintenance.
Mount Richmond Hotel
8.8Appreciated by guests for its proximity to the airport and town.
Quest Highbrook
8.9Convenient location near motorway, but parking is a downside.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
9.5Great location around the lake and near shopping, with nice views.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
9.1Positive feedback on the location being close to amenities.
Mount Richmond Hotel
8.7Multiple positive mentions of friendly and helpful staff across reviews.
Quest Highbrook
9.3Reception staff were welcoming and friendly, with good service throughout the stay.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
9.4Great staff with actual personalities, though there were some issues with staff communication.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
10.0Multiple mentions of friendly staff and good reception service.
Mount Richmond Hotel
—Quest Highbrook
—Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
—Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
—Mount Richmond Hotel
6.2Issues noted with restaurant availability and cleanliness in serving areas.
Quest Highbrook
8.4Limited food options in the area and complaints about milk supply for coffee.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
7.5Food could be better; some confusion regarding breakfast inclusion.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
6.1Restaurant closed and limited options noted.
Mount Richmond Hotel
7.2Facilities mentioned positively but noted some were outdated or in disrepair.
Quest Highbrook
8.6Good amenities overall, but limited food options and issues with bathrooms noted.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
8.4Some amenities were seen as tired; overall a good range.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
6.1Facilities like the pool and restaurant were not available.
Mount Richmond Hotel
7.2Guests felt the price was fair for the conditions offered.
Quest Highbrook
8.8Good price for the quality provided, but some complaints about extra charges.
Waipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
8.4Good value based on location and comfort.
Best Western Ellerslie International Hotel
8.6Price considered high given the amenities and service issues.
Mount Richmond Hotel
McManus ParkQuest Highbrook
Swirling BullWaipuna Hotel & Conference Centre
Ireland Road Tree GroveBest Western Ellerslie International Hotel
Ellerslie Domain