Our pick
English
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.8Rooms were noted as clean and comfortable, but some fittings were getting a bit tired.
Cleanliness
8.8The room was noted to be beautiful and clean, but some guests mentioned minor disturbances from other guests.
Location
9.3Beautiful location with a lovely atmosphere, but some confusion regarding the entrances.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Old Mill8.8
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort8.1
Cleanliness
The Old Mill8.8
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort7.6
Location
The Old Mill9.3
The Mayflower8.8
Service
The Old Mill9.6
The Mayflower8.9
Food & Breakfast
The Mayflower8.8
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort7.1
Value
The Mayflower8.6
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort7.5
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort amenity advantages
SaunaConcierge serviceFence around poolFitness facilitiesConference space
The Mayflower amenity advantages
Meeting/banquet facilities
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.6 km.
The Mayflower: 0.87 km (0.54 mi)
The Old Mill: 4.4 km (2.8 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
8.2/10The Mayflower
8.6/10The Walhampton Arms
8.8/10The Old Mill
8.9/10Rooms
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
8.1Room quality overall was good, but some issues with outdated furniture.
The Mayflower
8.3Room was fantastic with beautiful views, but some decor could use sprucing up.
The Walhampton Arms
8.6Rooms were spacious, cozy, and well-appointed.
The Old Mill
8.8Rooms were noted as clean and comfortable, but some fittings were getting a bit tired.
Cleanliness
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
7.6Inconsistent cleanliness noted, with some areas needing more attention.
The Mayflower
8.4Rooms were lovely and immaculately clean as was the whole place.
The Walhampton Arms
8.7Rooms were clean and comfortable; some minor maintenance issues noted.
The Old Mill
8.8The room was noted to be beautiful and clean, but some guests mentioned minor disturbances from other guests.
Location
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
9.1Beautiful location with lovely views.
The Mayflower
8.8Located by the Quay with a lovely walk to the main high street.
The Walhampton Arms
9.1Beautiful and quiet location with nearby countryside; ideal for a relaxing break.
The Old Mill
9.3Beautiful location with a lovely atmosphere, but some confusion regarding the entrances.
Service
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
9.1Staff were very helpful and friendly.
The Mayflower
8.9Staff were friendly and attentive, providing excellent customer service.
The Walhampton Arms
9.3Staff were friendly, helpful, and welcoming throughout our stay.
The Old Mill
9.6Staff were consistently described as friendly, attentive, and welcoming, providing exceptional service.
Sleep & Noise
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
—The Mayflower
—The Walhampton Arms
—The Old Mill
—Food & Breakfast
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
7.1Breakfast price noted as a downside.
The Mayflower
8.8Breakfast was freshly cooked with plenty of choice; excellent food overall.
The Walhampton Arms
8.8Excellent food quality, but limited menu choices for dinner.
The Old Mill
7.8Breakfast received negative feedback for quality, but other food options were appreciated.
Amenities & Facilities
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
8.6Facilities including pool and sports options were highly rated.
The Mayflower
8.4Facilities included a lovely pub and restaurant with high-quality breakfast.
The Walhampton Arms
8.6Some amenities were good, but lacking in comfy seating options.
The Old Mill
8.8General amenities were not heavily criticized, with some positive mentions regarding the facilities.
Value
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
7.5Some guests felt it was overpriced for the quality.
The Mayflower
8.6Significantly cheaper than town center premises with ample parking.
The Walhampton Arms
8.5Good overall value, but had issues with evening dining restrictions.
The Old Mill
8.6While some guests felt the dining options were overpriced, overall value was considered decent.
Landmarks
Macdonald Elmers Court Resort
Lymington ObeliskThe Mayflower
Bath Road Recreation GroundThe Walhampton Arms
Lymington ObeliskThe Old Mill
Arnewood Court